Is Colby cheese gluten-free?
Plain Colby and Colby Jack: block, sliced, shredded or snack-stick cheese
Naturally gluten-free“The most cost-effective and healthy way to follow the gluten-free diet is to seek out these naturally gluten-free food groups, which include: Fruits Vegetables Meat and poultry Fish and seafood Dairy Beans, legumes, and nuts” Celiac Disease Foundation, read Nov 16, 2026 [1] · From the Celiac Disease Foundation’s Gluten-Free Foods page; it lists dairy as a group and does not name Colby.
2 of 11 products we checked contain gluten: Sargento Balanced Breaks Pepper Jack & Colby-Jack Cheeses with RITZ Mini crackers (6-pack) and Sargento Balanced Breaks Cheese + Crunch Mix, Colby-Jack with BBQ snack mix (3-pack).
Colby cheese is naturally gluten-free in its plain form: the FDA’s standard defines it as prepared from milk and other ingredients specified in the standard, and the Celiac Disease Foundation lists dairy among naturally gluten-free food groups. Colby Jack kits sold with crackers or snack mix differ, because they list wheat.
- Snack kits that pair Colby Jack with crackers or snack mix add wheat: Sargento’s Ritz Mini cracker kit lists enriched wheat flour, the ingredient list of its Cheese + Crunch Mix tray includes enriched wheat flour, barley malt and wheat gluten, and Sargento’s FAQ says Balanced Breaks Cheese and Crackers varieties that include wheat flour and other wheat or barley ingredients contain gluten. The cheese is not the source; the crackers and mix are. [12, 13, 3]
- The plain Colby and Colby Jack pages we read list only milk, culture, salt, enzymes and annatto, and the shredded cheeses we read add an anti-caking agent: Sargento and Tillamook list potato starch, and Sargento also lists powdered cellulose and says neither agent “is derived from wheat, rye, barley, or their cross-bred hybrids”. [4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 3]
- Only one maker page we read calls Colby gluten-free: Dietz & Watson’s Colby Cheese page lists gluten free among its attributes, while its Colby Jack block page lists none. Sargento, Tillamook and Organic Valley pages make no such claim, and GFCO’s directory returned no products for Sargento, Tillamook or Dietz & Watson and lists one Colby Jack product by Augason Farms. [10, 11, 4, 7, 9, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18]
- This covers Colby and Colby Jack sold in the US; we didn’t check other countries’ products, restaurant dishes made with Colby, or flavored and seasoned Colby spreads and snacks.
Colby cheese: the products we checked

| Product | Verdict | What decides it |
|---|---|---|
| Sargento Colby Sliced Cheese (11 slices) | Not labeled gluten-free | The list names only pasteurized milk, cheese culture, salt, enzymes and annatto; the page makes no gluten-free claim. [4, 15] |
| Sargento Colby-Jack Sliced Cheese (24 slices) | Not labeled gluten-free | The list names only pasteurized milk, cheese culture, salt, enzymes and annatto; the page makes no gluten-free claim. [5, 15] |
| Sargento Colby-Jack Shredded Cheese, Fine Cut (8 oz) | Not labeled gluten-free | The list names the cheese, potato starch, powdered cellulose and natamycin, no gluten grain; the page makes no gluten-free claim. [6, 3, 15] |
| Tillamook Colby Jack Cheese Block | Not labeled gluten-free | The page lists cultured pasteurized milk, salt, enzymes and annatto and declares only milk as an allergen; it makes no gluten-free claim. [7, 16] |
| Tillamook Colby Jack Farmstyle Shredded Cheese (8 oz) | Not labeled gluten-free | The list names Colby and Monterey Jack cheese, potato starch and natamycin, no gluten grain; the page makes no gluten-free claim. [8, 16] |
| Organic Valley Organic Colby Jack Cheese Sticks | Not labeled gluten-free | The list names organic milk, salt, vegetarian enzyme and annatto; the page makes no gluten-free claim and GFCO shows no Organic Valley cheese listing. [9, 18] |
| Dietz & Watson Colby Cheese | Labeled gluten-free | The maker’s page lists gluten free among its product attributes, and its ingredient list names no gluten grain; GFCO returned no Dietz products. [10, 17] |
| Dietz & Watson Colby Jack Cheese (block page) | Not labeled gluten-free | The list names only milk, salt, cultures, enzymes and annatto; unlike its Colby Cheese page, this page’s attributes include no gluten-free claim. [11, 10, 17] |
| Augason Farms Colby Jack cheese (GFCO listing, 30.19 oz) | Certified gluten-free | GFCO’s directory lists “AF Dairy FD ColbyJackCheese 30.19oz #10” by Augason Farms; we did not read a maker page for it, so only the listing was read. [14] |
| Sargento Balanced Breaks Pepper Jack & Colby-Jack Cheeses with RITZ Mini crackers (6-pack) | Contains gluten | The crackers list enriched wheat flour, and Sargento’s FAQ says Balanced Breaks Cheese and Crackers varieties that include wheat flour and other wheat or barley ingredients contain gluten; the cheese is not the source. [12, 3] |
| Sargento Balanced Breaks Cheese + Crunch Mix, Colby-Jack with BBQ snack mix (3-pack) | Contains gluten | The tray’s ingredient list includes enriched wheat flour, barley malt and wheat gluten, and the page says Contains: Milk, Wheat, Cashews. [13] |
Certification and shared equipment
GFCO’s directory search for colby returns one product, Augason Farms’ Colby Jack, and the directory says a listed product is certified only if its package also carries a certification mark. Searches for Sargento, Tillamook and Dietz return no products, and the Organic Valley search shows no Organic Valley product. [14, 15, 16, 17, 18]
Sargento’s FAQ says gluten is not generally found in natural cheeses but there is always the possibility of a trace amount being introduced during the cheese making process. The Gluten Intolerance Group says prepared foods such as cheeses could be gluten-free but anything prepared, pre-seasoned or otherwise altered from its natural state could contain gluten. We did not find a may-contain or shared-equipment line on the plain Colby pages we read. [3, 2, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11]
Questions readers ask
Are the anti-caking agents in shredded Colby Jack a gluten source?
Not in the Sargento bag we read: it lists potato starch and powdered cellulose, and Sargento says neither is derived from wheat, rye, barley or their cross-bred hybrids. Tillamook’s shredded Colby Jack lists potato starch, so read the bag’s own list. [3, 6, 8]
Sources and how we checked
We read every source below on the date shown and quote it exactly. How we check a verdict explains each verdict; if anything here is out of date, report it on the corrections page.
- Gluten-Free Foods
- Gluten-Free Farm-to-Table
- Sargento FAQ
- Sargento Colby Sliced Cheese, 11 Slices
- Sargento Colby-Jack Sliced Cheese, 24 Slices
- Sargento Colby-Jack Shredded Cheese, Fine Cut, 8 oz.
- Colby Jack Cheese Block
- Colby Jack Farmstyle Shredded Cheese
- Organic Colby Jack Cheese Sticks
- Colby Cheese
- Colby Jack Cheese (block)
- Balanced Breaks Cheese & Crackers, Pepper Jack & Colby-Jack Cheeses and RITZ Mini Original Crackers Snack Kit, 6-Pack
- Balanced Breaks Cheese + Crunch Mix Colby-Jack Cheese and Smoky & Sweet BBQ Seasoned Snack Mix, 3-Pack
- GFCO Product Finder search for colby
- GFCO Product Finder search for Sargento
- GFCO Product Finder search for Tillamook
- GFCO Product Finder search for Dietz
- GFCO Product Finder search for Organic Valley
- Questions and Answers on the Gluten-Free Food Labeling Final Rule | FDA