Is sheep milk gluten-free?
Plain sheep milk
Naturally gluten-free“The most cost-effective and healthy way to follow the gluten-free diet is to seek out these naturally gluten-free food groups, which include: Fruits Vegetables Meat and poultry Fish and seafood Dairy Beans, legumes, and nuts” Celiac Disease Foundation, read Nov 16, 2026 [1] · From the foundation’s gluten-free foods page; it lists dairy as a group and does not name sheep milk, and we read it on Nov 16, 2026.
Sheep milk is naturally gluten-free in its plain form, as dairy: the Celiac Disease Foundation lists dairy, and the Gluten Intolerance Group lists plain dairy products, among naturally gluten-free foods, though neither names sheep milk. Bellwether Farms’ FAQ says all varieties of its yogurt are naturally gluten free; flavored and processed versions are the ones to check.
- The Gluten Intolerance Group says processed or flavored versions of these foods, which include plain dairy products, may have gluten-containing ingredients. Old Chatham’s plain sheep milk yogurt lists only sheep milk and cultures, while its flavored cups and pouch add cane sugar and flavorings (fruit, vanilla or natural flavors), most with pectin and vegetable juice; none of those lists names a gluten grain, but a flavored sheep milk product needs its own label read. [2, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15]
- Makers word it differently: Bellwether’s FAQ says “Yes all varieties of our yogurt are naturally gluten free”, an answer about all of its yogurt, which also includes Jersey cow milk yogurt, while Old Chatham’s FAQ says its yogurt “isn't currently certified gluten-free” but “contains no gluten”, so we list Old Chatham’s as not labeled gluten-free. [3, 10]
- Bellwether’s product pages carry the ingredient list in an image panel, not in text. We read the 6 oz panels for plain, vanilla, blackberry and strawberry: none names a gluten grain, and the flavored ones add cane sugar plus vanilla or fruit with pectin and citric acid. Its sell sheet is marked © 2016, so we rely on the panels for the current lists. [4, 5, 6, 7, 8]
- This covers sheep milk yogurt sold in the US by two makers; we didn’t check bottled or raw sheep milk, sheep milk cheese, powder, ice cream, store brands, Bellwether’s other flavors and sizes, or other countries’ products.
Sheep milk: the products we checked

| Product | Verdict | What decides it |
|---|---|---|
| Old Chatham Plain Sheep Milk Yogurt (5.3 oz) | Not labeled gluten-free | The page lists pasteurized sheep milk and live and active cultures; the FAQ says the yogurt “isn't currently certified gluten-free” but “contains no gluten”. [11, 10] |
| Old Chatham Field Berry Sheep Milk Yogurt (5.3 oz) | Not labeled gluten-free | The list names sheep milk, strawberries, cane sugar, natural flavors, pectin, vegetable juice and cultures; no gluten-free claim. [12, 10] |
| Old Chatham Peaches & Cream Sheep Milk Yogurt (5.3 oz) | Not labeled gluten-free | The list names sheep milk, peaches, cane sugar, natural flavors, pectin, vegetable juice and cultures; no gluten-free claim. [13, 10] |
| Old Chatham Vanilla Bean Sheep Milk Yogurt (5.3 oz) | Not labeled gluten-free | The list names sheep milk, cane sugar, vanilla extract, vanilla bean and cultures; no gluten-free claim. [14, 10] |
| Old Chatham Cotton Candy Sheep Milk Yogurt Pouch (3.5 oz) | Not labeled gluten-free | The list names sheep milk, cane sugar, natural flavors, pectin, vegetable juice, lemon juice concentrate and cultures; no gluten-free claim. [15, 10] |
| Bellwether Farms Plain Sheep Milk Yogurt | Labeled gluten-free | Bellwether’s FAQ says “Yes all varieties of our yogurt are naturally gluten free”; the plain page’s ingredient panel lists sheep milk and cultures, and no gluten ingredient is named. [3, 4, 5] |
| Bellwether Farms Vanilla, Blackberry and Strawberry Sheep Milk Yogurt | Labeled gluten-free | Bellwether’s FAQ says “Yes all varieties of our yogurt are naturally gluten free”; the three pages’ ingredient panels add cane sugar, vanilla or fruit, pectin and citric acid, and none names a gluten ingredient. [3, 6, 7, 8] |
Certification and shared equipment
None of the sheep milk yogurt brands we searched is listed in the Gluten-Free Certification Organization directory: searches for Bellwether and Old Chatham each listed no products, and a search for sheep listed only sheep casing sausage. [9, 16, 17]
Old Chatham’s FAQ says its yogurt “is made in a facility that produces no gluten-containing products”. Bellwether’s FAQ page has no line about shared equipment or a shared facility. [10, 3]
Questions readers ask
Is Old Chatham sheep milk yogurt certified gluten-free?
No. Old Chatham’s FAQ says the yogurt isn't currently certified gluten-free but contains no gluten, and a search of the GFCO directory for Old Chatham listed no products. [10, 16]
Is flavored sheep milk yogurt gluten-free?
Not by default. The Gluten Intolerance Group says processed or flavored versions of foods like plain dairy may have gluten-containing ingredients. Old Chatham’s flavored yogurts list cane sugar, fruit or vanilla, natural flavors, pectin and vegetable juice, and none names a gluten grain. [2, 12, 13, 14, 15]
Sources and how we checked
We read every source below on the date shown and quote it exactly. How we check a verdict explains each verdict; if anything here is out of date, report it on the corrections page.
- Gluten-Free Foods
- Getting Started on a Gluten-Free Diet
- Frequently Asked Questions
- Sheep Milk Yogurt–Plain
- Sheep Yogurt sell sheet (PDF)
- Vanilla Sheep Milk Yogurt
- Blackberry Sheep Milk Yogurt
- Strawberry Sheep Milk Yogurt
- GFCO Product Finder search for Bellwether
- FAQs
- Plain Sheep Milk Yogurt 5.3 oz
- Field Berry Sheep Milk Yogurt 5.3 oz
- Peaches & Cream Sheep Milk Yogurt 5.3 oz
- Vanilla Bean Sheep Milk Yogurt 5.3 oz
- Cotton Candy Sheep Milk Yogurt Pouch 3.5 oz
- GFCO Product Finder search for Old Chatham
- GFCO Product Finder search for sheep