Celiac disease or IBS: overlapping symptoms and what guidelines say about testing

Short answer

Celiac disease and IBS share symptoms11, and the American College of Gastroenterology’s IBS guideline recommends celiac blood testing for people with IBS and diarrhea symptoms1. The ACG’s celiac guideline says blood testing is done while on a regular, gluten-containing diet2. The guideline notes that the North American data behind it are limited3.

Published by Gluten Verdict · updated · 14 sources, each linked below

Reviewed by Mark Peter, Registered dietitian (RD), on

Office desk with a calendar, pen, red stapler and a half-finished lunch container

Key points

  • The ACG’s IBS guideline recommends serologic testing to rule out celiac disease in patients with IBS and diarrhea symptoms1.
  • A 2009 meta-analysis found the prevalence of biopsy-proved celiac disease in people meeting IBS criteria was more than 4-fold that in controls without IBS4; a 2017 update says screening’s usefulness in North America or the community is less clear5.
  • NIDDK says doctors don’t recommend starting a gluten-free diet before diagnostic testing, because the diet can affect test results6.
  • For people without IgA deficiency, the ACG celiac guideline says a negative TTG IgA test can be considered to adequately rule out celiac disease when the pretest probability is low or moderate7.
  • NIDDK’s list of foods that contain FODMAPs includes wheat and rye products8; NIDDK describes gluten as a protein found in wheat, barley and rye40.

Why do celiac disease and IBS get mixed up?

Both are common. The ACG’s celiac guideline says celiac disease affects nearly 1% of US residents9, and NIDDK says studies suggest about 12 percent of people in the United States have IBS10.

They also share digestive symptoms. The ACG’s IBS guideline says many people with celiac disease have abdominal pain, bloating or altered bowel habits, which can be mistaken for IBS11. NIDDK says celiac disease is not diagnosed on symptoms alone, because some of its symptoms are like those of other digestive disorders, such as IBS or lactose intolerance12.

The Celiac Disease Foundation describes celiac disease, non-celiac gluten sensitivity and IBS as separate disorders with very similar symptoms, which often need specialists to sort out13.

This page reports what guidelines and health agencies say. A symptom list cannot tell you which condition you have, and nothing here is medical advice.

How the two compare, as NIDDK describes them

Each cell comes from the NIDDK page named by its marker. The table shows how one source describes each condition. It is a reference, not a self-check.

Celiac disease and IBS in NIDDK’s words
FeatureCeliac diseaseIBS
What it isConsuming gluten triggers an abnormal immune system reaction that damages the small intestine14.A group of symptoms with no visible signs of damage or disease in the digestive tract15. A functional disorder, which doctors now call a disorder of gut-brain interactions16.
Digestive symptoms listedBloating, chronic diarrhea, constipation, gas, abdominal pain and others17.Repeated abdominal pain and changes in bowel movements: diarrhea, constipation, or both15.
Symptoms outside the digestive tractSome people have them, including fatigue, joint or bone pain and dermatitis herpetiformis18.NIDDK’s IBS page names other health problems people with IBS often have, such as fibromyalgia, reflux, anxiety and depression19.
AnemiaBlood tests may show signs of health problems that could be related to celiac disease, such as anemia20.Listed among symptoms that may suggest another health problem instead of IBS, with rectal bleeding, bloody or black tarry stools, and weight loss21.
How doctors diagnose itMost often with blood tests and biopsies of the small intestine6.From the symptom pattern29; in most cases doctors don’t use tests to diagnose IBS, though they may order tests to check for other health problems22.
Role of glutenResearch suggests celiac disease only occurs in people who have certain genes and eat food that contains gluten23.Some people with IBS have more symptoms after eating gluten, even though they do not have celiac disease24.
Diet NIDDK describesDoctors treat celiac disease by helping people to follow a gluten-free diet25.A doctor may suggest more fiber, avoiding gluten, or the low FODMAP diet; different changes may help different people26, 27.

Read across the rows, the shared ground is digestive: abdominal pain, diarrhea and constipation17, 15. Where the pages part ways is in what the condition is and how it is confirmed: see the first and fifth rows.

How IBS is diagnosed, and where celiac disease comes in

NIDDK says doctors diagnose IBS by reviewing your symptoms and your medical and family history and performing a physical exam28. The pattern it describes is abdominal pain with two or more of: pain related to bowel movements, a change in how often you have a bowel movement, and a change in how stools look, over a period it sets out in the same section29.

NIDDK adds that doctors may order blood tests, stool tests and other tests to check for other health problems22. Its list of possible other tests includes an upper GI endoscopy with a biopsy to check for celiac disease, and it says a family history of digestive diseases such as celiac disease is among the factors behind that choice30.

The ACG’s IBS guideline suggests a “positive diagnostic strategy” rather than a diagnosis of exclusion31. It describes that as a careful history, a physical examination and a standard definition, with limited diagnostic tests32.

The Celiac Disease Foundation, in a 2019 article summarizing a literature review, puts the emphasis differently: it says IBS and non-celiac gluten sensitivity both lack a reliable biomarker, so a doctor who suspects either must first rule out other possibilities, such as celiac disease33.

What the ACG IBS guideline says about celiac blood tests

The American College of Gastroenterology published an IBS guideline in 2021 (Lacy and colleagues, American Journal of Gastroenterology). Its recommendation: serologic testing to rule out celiac disease in patients with IBS and diarrhea symptoms, rated a strong recommendation with moderate quality of evidence1.

The guideline gives its reasons: the evidence of increased odds of celiac disease among people with IBS symptoms, the significant potential consequences of missing the diagnosis, the availability of highly effective treatment, and the apparent cost-effectiveness of an early diagnosis3.

For the test itself, the IBS guideline points to the ACG’s celiac guideline, which recommends serological screening with immunoglobulin A (IgA) tissue transglutaminase and a quantitative IgA level34. Our celiac blood test guide covers what these results look like.

The ACG’s celiac guideline makes a broader statement: testing should be considered in patients with signs or symptoms suggestive of celiac disease, including diarrhea, weight loss, abdominal pain and bloating35.

How often celiac disease turns up in people with IBS symptoms

A 2009 systematic review and meta-analysis (Ford and colleagues, Archives of Internal Medicine) concluded that the prevalence of biopsy-proved celiac disease in cases meeting diagnostic criteria for IBS was more than 4-fold that in controls without IBS4.

A 2017 update (Irvine, Chey and Ford, American Journal of Gastroenterology) found the prevalence of positive celiac serology and biopsy-proven celiac disease significantly higher in people with symptoms suggestive of IBS than in healthy controls. It also concluded that the usefulness of screening for celiac disease in people with suspected IBS in North America or in the community is less clear5.

The ACG’s IBS guideline reports the same limit: only a small number of the included studies were conducted in North America, and these did not identify a difference in the odds of positive serology or biopsy-proven celiac disease between people with IBS symptoms and controls36. The guideline still recommends testing, and says the limited North American data are recognized3.

Celiac disease by IBS subtype, as the ACG IBS guideline reports the Irvine meta-analysis
IBS subtypePrevalence of celiac disease by EMA or tTG (95% confidence interval)
IBS with diarrhea (IBS-D)5.7% (3.0%–9.1%)37
IBS with mixed or alternating bowel habits (IBS-M)3.4% (1.4%–6.2%)37
IBS with constipation (IBS-C)2.1% (0.9%–3.8%)37

These are pooled figures from many studies, not the likelihood for any one person.

Why the celiac test needs gluten in the diet

NIDDK says doctors don’t recommend starting a gluten-free diet before diagnostic testing, because a gluten-free diet can affect test results6. The ACG’s celiac guideline says serologic testing should measure TTG IgA while on a regular (gluten-containing) diet, with total IgA measured at the same time if IgA deficiency has not been checked2.

For people who have already stopped gluten, the ACG says HLA testing is central to the approach and that, with a celiac-compatible haplotype, a gluten challenge can be offered38. NIDDK says that without the DQ2 or DQ8 gene variants celiac disease is very unlikely, and that having them alone does not mean you have it39. Our guides cover the gluten challenge and the DQ2 and DQ8 genes.

A gluten-free trial for IBS symptoms is a different step from celiac testing. NIDDK describes it as something a doctor may recommend to see whether IBS symptoms improve40; the sources above explain why the order matters for a later celiac test6.

If the celiac tests are negative

The ACG celiac guideline says a negative TTG IgA in patients without IgA deficiency has a high negative predictive value when the pretest probability is low or moderate, and that celiac disease can then be considered adequately ruled out. For patients with high pretest probability, it says EGD with duodenal biopsy should be considered even with a negative serology7. See also our guides on IgA deficiency and celiac testing and seronegative celiac disease.

Gluten can still matter in IBS. NIDDK says some people with IBS have more symptoms after eating gluten even though they do not have celiac disease24. The ACG’s IBS guideline says sensitivity to gluten is one of the most commonly reported reactions to food among people with IBS, and in many it is believed to be a non-immune event, possibly even a reaction to the carbohydrate fructan41.

The Celiac Disease Foundation’s 2019 summary of a literature review says the review’s authors found multiple studies where people with IBS-D had statistically significant improvements on a gluten-free diet compared with a gluten challenge diet42. It adds that many of the studies were heterogeneous, using different amounts of gluten and durations, which makes them harder to compare43. Our guide on celiac disease versus gluten intolerance covers non-celiac gluten sensitivity.

When symptoms continue on a gluten-free diet

The overlap runs both ways. NIDDK says that in about 20 percent of people with celiac disease, symptoms continue or come back even while they follow a gluten-free diet44. It lists three possible causes: small amounts of gluten, other health problems, or refractory celiac disease45. Among other health problems, it names irritable bowel syndrome, lactose intolerance, microscopic colitis, problems with the pancreas and small intestinal bacterial overgrowth46.

One 2013 meta-analysis of adults with celiac disease (Sainsbury, Sanders and Ford) found a pooled prevalence of IBS-type symptoms of 38.0%47.

The ACG defines nonresponsive celiac disease as persistent or recurrent symptoms despite being on a gluten-free diet, and says these patients need a systematic workup to rule out specific conditions, especially unintentional gluten contamination48. NIDDK’s advice is to talk with a doctor or a registered dietitian, who can help find the cause49.

Low-FODMAP and gluten-free diets: what each can show

Wheat and rye products are on NIDDK’s list of foods that contain FODMAPs8, and NIDDK describes gluten as a protein found in wheat, barley and rye40. The ACG’s IBS guideline describes how FODMAPs may cause symptoms: they increase water secretion and fermentation in the colon, producing short-chain fatty acids and gases that can distend the bowel and trigger meal-related symptoms in IBS50.

The ACG’s IBS guideline recommends a limited trial of a low FODMAP diet in patients with IBS, a conditional recommendation based on very low quality evidence51. A 2018 meta-analysis (Dionne and colleagues) concluded that there is insufficient evidence to recommend a gluten-free diet to reduce IBS symptoms, and very low quality evidence that a low FODMAP diet reduces them52.

The ACG describes the low FODMAP diet in three stages: substituting foods, gradually reintroducing them while assessing symptoms, and personalizing the diet53. It says the committee believes the low FODMAP diet’s complexity, with the potential for nutritional deficiencies, calls for a properly trained GI dietitian54.

In short, as the sources frame it: a gluten-free trial can change what a celiac test shows6, while a limited low-FODMAP trial is a dietary step the ACG’s IBS guideline recommends51. Which, if either, to try, and when, is a decision for the person’s clinician.

Raising the question with a clinician

Nothing here suggests anyone missed something: the ACG’s recommendation concerns IBS with diarrhea symptoms, and its own text notes the limited North American data3. These are questions that follow from what the sources say a celiac workup involves. They are not a substitute for a clinician’s judgment.

  • Was celiac serology part of my IBS evaluation? The ACG’s IBS guideline names it for IBS with diarrhea symptoms1, and describes it as IgA tissue transglutaminase with a quantitative IgA level34.
  • If it was done, was I eating gluten at the time? The ACG says the test is done on a regular, gluten-containing diet2.
  • If I have already cut out gluten, what testing does my clinician suggest? The ACG describes HLA testing and a gluten challenge as part of that approach38.
  • If a gluten-free or low-FODMAP diet is on the table, is a dietitian involved? NIDDK says a doctor may recommend talking with a dietitian27.

Questions people ask

Can celiac disease be mistaken for IBS?

The ACG’s IBS guideline says the abdominal pain, bloating and altered bowel habits many people with celiac disease have can be mistaken for IBS11. NIDDK says celiac disease isn’t diagnosed on symptoms alone12.

Do IBS guidelines recommend a celiac blood test?

The ACG’s 2021 IBS guideline recommends serologic testing to rule out celiac disease in patients with IBS and diarrhea symptoms1. It also notes the limited North American data3.

Can I start a gluten-free diet before a celiac test?

NIDDK says doctors don’t recommend it, because a gluten-free diet can affect test results6. The ACG says the blood test is done on a regular, gluten-containing diet2.

Is a gluten-free diet recommended for IBS?

A 2018 meta-analysis found insufficient evidence to recommend one to reduce IBS symptoms52. NIDDK says a doctor may recommend avoiding gluten to see if IBS symptoms improve40.

More in Celiac diagnosis, testing and gluten sensitivity

Sources