Gluten-free and low FODMAP: what to check when symptoms continue

Short answer

Gluten and FODMAPs are different things2, 23. When symptoms continue on a gluten-free diet, the American College of Gastroenterology calls for a systematic workup1, and Monash University says its low-FODMAP diet is intended for people with medically diagnosed IBS27. The workup includes:

  1. Reviewing and confirming the original diagnosis4.
  2. Evaluating for inadvertent gluten exposure, through an expert dietitian and serology4.
  3. Assessing for a coexisting functional disorder, such as irritable bowel syndrome4, 5.
  4. Selective testing, based on clinical suspicion, for food intolerances (lactose, fructose), pancreatic insufficiency, microscopic colitis and small intestinal bacterial overgrowth, among others4.

Published by Gluten Verdict · updated · 11 sources, each linked below

Reviewed by Mark Peter, Registered dietitian (RD), on

Cook seen from behind at a stove, with garlic, onion and scallion greens on a board

Key points

  • FODMAPs are short-chain carbohydrates that are not absorbed properly in the gut23; celiac disease is an immune-mediated response to gluten present in wheat, barley and rye2.
  • Coeliac UK says ongoing symptoms after starting a gluten-free diet affect around 1 in 3 people, and most of the time gluten is still getting into the diet8.
  • Monash says its low-FODMAP diet is best followed under a qualified dietitian or healthcare professional experienced in it28, the Celiac Disease Foundation says it should be initiated only with a specialized dietitian22, and Monash describes a 2-6 week period of high restriction before foods are gradually re-introduced28.
  • A gluten-free label does not settle FODMAPs: Monash found gluten-free products, for example gluten-free pasta, that contain high-FODMAP ingredients such as soy flour or lupin flour37.
  • Monash names inulin, chicory root, apple juice and fruit juice concentrates among the label ingredients to look for33, 36.

Gluten and FODMAPs are different things

Celiac disease is an immune-mediated response to gluten present in wheat, barley and rye2. FODMAPs are a collection of short-chain carbohydrates that are not absorbed properly in the gut and can trigger symptoms in people with IBS; they occur naturally in many foods and food additives23.

Two separate questions
GlutenFODMAPs
What it isPresent in wheat, barley and rye2Short-chain carbohydrates not absorbed properly in the gut23
Where it turns upWheat, barley and rye2A wide range of foods, such as fruits, vegetables, breads, cereals, nuts, legumes and confectionery24

Wheat is where the two overlap. Monash lists wheat and rye, along with onions, garlic and legumes, among the foods that contain fructans and GOS, two kinds of FODMAP25. The Celiac Disease Foundation says that is why many clinicians and researchers think a gluten-free diet may ease IBS symptoms: it reduces the carbohydrates in wheat grains that gut bacteria ferment20.

This page reports what guidelines, NIDDK, Monash University and the charities say. It is written around celiac disease, which is what the ACG and Coeliac UK passages cover; it does not diagnose anything or replace the clinician who knows your history.

What a clinician checks when symptoms continue on a gluten-free diet

The American College of Gastroenterology (ACG) defines nonresponsive celiac disease as persistent or recurrent symptoms despite a gluten-free diet, and says these patients require a systematic workup to rule out the conditions that may cause them, especially unintentional gluten contamination1. A figure in the guideline puts the timeframe at 6–12 months of dietary gluten avoidance3.

It is not rare. Coeliac UK says ongoing symptoms after starting a gluten-free diet affect around 1 in 3 people, and that most of the time gluten is still getting into the diet8.

The ACG guideline text lists what the evaluation of persistent or recurrent symptoms takes into account:

  • Reviewing and confirming the initial diagnosis4.
  • Evaluation for inadvertent gluten exposure, through assessment by an expert dietitian and serology4.
  • Assessment for a coexisting functional disorder4; the guideline notes that many patients with celiac disease have ongoing symptoms attributed to functional disorders such as irritable bowel syndrome5.
  • Selective testing, based on clinical suspicion, of food intolerances (for example lactose and fructose), pancreatic insufficiency, microscopic colitis and small intestinal bacterial overgrowth, among others4.

Coeliac UK, writing for the UK, says the first step when non-responsive or refractory coeliac disease is suspected is usually an endoscopy with biopsy10, and that if the gut looks normal, other causes such as irritable bowel syndrome or lactose intolerance are considered11. It also says that with ongoing symptoms it is important not to guess the cause and to visit your healthcare team9.

Gluten exposure and follow-up blood tests

In a study presented at Digestive Disease Week and reported by Beyond Celiac, gluten exposure was the most frequent cause physicians cited among patients whose follow-up biopsy showed ongoing intestinal damage14.

The ACG guideline's figure on the workup says positive celiac serologies despite 12 months of treatment with a gluten-free diet suggest there may be ongoing gluten ingestion6. Beyond Celiac lists “Am I being exposed to gluten?” among the questions regular blood monitoring can help answer17, and adds that blood-test results do not always detect damage to the intestine16.

ACG is cautious about gluten-detection spot checks: it says there may be a role for them in select scenarios, but it is not given that the approach will improve adherence, quality of life or other clinical outcomes7.

For the kitchen side of hidden gluten, see our guide to gluten cross-contact at home and our reading of a tTG-IgA result.

Other causes clinicians consider

The Celiac Disease Foundation says continued gluten ingestion is the most common cause of persistent symptoms in both people with celiac disease and people with non-celiac gluten sensitivity, and that a dual diagnosis of irritable bowel syndrome is also common19.

In the same Digestive Disease Week study, among patients whose follow-up biopsy showed healing, physicians most frequently cited microscopic colitis or IBS for the ongoing symptoms13. Beyond Celiac notes that there is no test for IBS and that it is usually diagnosed when other conditions have been ruled out15.

Lactose is one of the intolerances both ACG and Coeliac UK name4, 11. Our guide to lactose intolerance after a celiac diagnosis covers it, and Monash points out that only people with lactose intolerance need to limit lactose38.

What a low-FODMAP trial is

Monash University, which developed the diet, says it is intended for people with medically diagnosed IBS, that someone whose symptoms a doctor has not diagnosed should not be following it, and that many conditions, coeliac disease among them, have symptoms similar to IBS27.

How three sources describe a trial
SourceWhat it says
Monash UniversityA 2-6 week period of high restriction, then a more relaxed diet where certain foods are gradually re-introduced28
Celiac Disease FoundationTemporarily eliminating trigger foods for a period of weeks, then reintroducing them slowly to determine individual causes of symptoms21
NIDDKA doctor may suggest trying it for a few weeks; if symptoms improve, the doctor may recommend slowly adding FODMAP foods back41

On who should guide it, Monash says the diet is best followed under the supervision of a qualified dietitian or healthcare professional experienced in it28. The Celiac Disease Foundation says it should be initiated only with a specialized dietitian, so that the least-restrictive diet can be found22. Gluten Intolerance Group adds that it is not meant to be followed indefinitely44.

Monash reports that IBS symptoms improved in 3 out of 4 people who follow it29, and also says that 1 out of 4 people with IBS find their symptoms do not improve on the diet30.

If you do not have celiac disease

Gluten Intolerance Group describes one study (Skodje and colleagues) in which 59 people without celiac disease on a gluten-free diet were given a granola bar containing gluten, fructans or a placebo; fructans caused more severe symptoms than gluten or the placebo45. It also says there is no laboratory test for FODMAP intolerance, so a FODMAP elimination diet, under the guidance of a Registered Dietitian or another healthcare professional, should be done to determine which foods are causing symptoms43.

FODMAP ingredients on gluten-free replacement foods

A gluten-free claim answers the gluten question only. Monash says many gluten-free products are lower in FODMAPs, but it has found a number of them, gluten-free pasta for example, that contain high-FODMAP ingredients such as soy flour or lupin flour37. It also says FODMAP content cannot be guessed: laboratory analysis is needed26.

FODMAP sources Monash and NIDDK list
Ingredient or foodWhat the source says
Inulin, chicory root or chicory root fibre, fructooligosaccharides (FOS), galactooligosaccharides (GOS)Monash says companies making gut-health claims often add them to boost prebiotic fibre, and that in some people with IBS this can cause gas, bloating and abdominal distension36. Purified forms such as inulin, FOS and GOS count even in very small amounts32.
Apple juice, pear juice and fruit juice concentratesMonash lists them as sources of excess fructose, with honey, high fructose corn syrup and glucose-fructose syrup33; the foods it names for this group include granola, muesli bars, bread and breakfast cereals34. NIDDK lists apples and pears or juice containing them, and honey and foods with high-fructose corn syrup42.
Soy flour, chickpea flour, Jerusalem artichokeMonash lists them with the oligosaccharide sources (GOS and fructans)35.
Sorbitol, mannitol, xylitol, maltitolNIDDK lists products, including candy and gum, with sweeteners ending in “–ol”42.
Milk, yogurt, ice creamNIDDK lists dairy products such as milk, milk products, soft cheeses, yogurt, custard and ice cream42.

Our verdict pages answer the gluten question only; they do not rate FODMAP content. For the foods above, the gluten side is at honey, high fructose corn syrup, apple juice, bread, pasta, cereal, granola bars, hummus, chickpeas and milk.

Reading one label for both questions

  1. Start with gluten: the gluten-free claim, the Contains line and the full ingredient list, as in our guide to reading a US food label for gluten.
  2. Then read the same list for the FODMAP ingredients in the table above. Monash notes that ingredients are listed in weight order and says to be particularly careful if a typically high-FODMAP food is listed in the first few ingredients31.
  3. Check separately for purified FODMAPs such as inulin, FOS and GOS, and for onion and garlic: Monash gives these as the exceptions to the weight-order rule, saying even very small amounts contribute significantly to the overall FODMAP load32.

Monash says products carrying its Low FODMAP Certified stamp have been laboratory tested against its criteria in the serving size on the pack39, and that the information in barcode-scanning apps is not regulated and often inaccurate40.

Why bacterial overgrowth questions go to a clinician

ACG lists small intestinal bacterial overgrowth among the conditions to test for selectively when symptoms persist4. Beyond Celiac lists it among the conditions whose symptoms overlap with celiac disease18, and NICE's public information for the UK says a doctor may check for an abnormally high level of bacteria in the intestine12.

None of the sources read for this page says whether a low-FODMAP diet suits that situation, so this guide does not either. It is a question for the clinician doing the testing.

Verdicts in this guide

Questions people ask

Is gluten-free the same as low FODMAP?

No. Celiac disease is a response to gluten present in wheat, barley and rye2. FODMAPs are short-chain carbohydrates that are not absorbed properly in the gut23. Wheat and rye contain fructans, one kind of FODMAP, but so do onions, garlic and legumes25.

Does a gluten-free label mean a food is low FODMAP?

No. Monash found a number of gluten-free products, for example gluten-free pasta, that contain high-FODMAP ingredients such as soy flour or lupin flour37.

Can I start a low-FODMAP diet on my own?

Monash says the diet is best followed under the supervision of a qualified dietitian or healthcare professional28, and that someone whose symptoms a doctor has not diagnosed should not be following it27. The Celiac Disease Foundation says it should be initiated only with a specialized dietitian22.

How long does the restriction phase last?

Monash describes a 2-6 week period of high restriction followed by gradual re-introduction28. NIDDK says a doctor may suggest trying it for a few weeks41.

More in Nutrition and combining diets

Sources