Wheat allergy tests vs celiac tests: which test answers which condition

Short answer

Celiac disease and wheat allergy are different conditions10, and the sources describe separate tests for each:

  1. Celiac disease: a blood test for TTG IgA antibodies taken while eating gluten, then biopsies of the small intestine to confirm, in the American College of Gastroenterology (ACG) guideline1, 2.
  2. Wheat allergy: Stanford’s allergy center names skin prick tests, IgE antibody levels and oral food challenges3; the NIAID-sponsored expert panel, writing about food allergy in general, says a thorough history is very important but not diagnostic alone29, and calls the double-blind placebo-controlled food challenge the gold standard4.
  3. Both at once: the Gluten Intolerance Group (GIG) says a person can have a wheat allergy and celiac disease6.

Published by Gluten Verdict · updated · 10 sources, each linked below

Reviewed by Mark Peter, Registered dietitian (RD), on

Car keys with a large red tag on a lab slip on a dashboard.

Key points

  • The antibodies differ: Stanford’s allergy center says celiac disease produces IgA or IgG antibodies, not the IgE antibodies that go with wheat allergy11.
  • NIAID’s food allergy guidelines say they do not discuss celiac disease, so an allergy guideline is not a celiac guideline38.
  • A positive skin prick test or IgE blood test alone does not make a food allergy diagnosis, according to the NIAID panel and FARE30, 32, 34.
  • NIDDK says doctors don’t recommend starting a gluten-free diet before celiac testing, because the diet can affect test results18.
  • GIG says a gastroenterologist usually diagnoses celiac disease and an allergist usually completes the testing for an IgE food allergy such as wheat allergy12, 13.

Two different immune reactions to wheat

ACG defines celiac disease as a permanent immune-mediated response to gluten present in wheat, barley and rye7. FARE describes it as an autoimmune disease in which antibodies are produced in response to gluten, with inflammation and damage to the lining of the small intestine8. Wheat allergy is a different mechanism: FARE describes an IgE-mediated reaction to proteins in wheat9.

Mayo Clinic says the two are sometimes confused but are different conditions10.

The two conditions as the sources describe them
Celiac diseaseWheat allergy
Type of immune reactionAutoimmune5An immune but not autoimmune response; IgE-mediated5, 9
AntibodiesIgA or IgG11IgE11
What the reaction involvesInflammation and damage to the lining of the small intestine8Skin, gastrointestinal tract and respiratory symptoms, and anaphylaxis in some people9
Who usually makes the diagnosis (GIG)A gastroenterologist12An allergist13
The diet the sources describeA gluten-free diet for life14Avoiding any form of wheat; GIG says a person with wheat allergy does not have trouble tolerating gluten from non-wheat sources15

Mayo Clinic says wheat allergy symptoms are likely to appear within minutes to hours after eating something containing wheat16. NIDDK says celiac disease isn’t diagnosed based on symptoms alone17.

What celiac testing looks for

The ACG guideline starts with a blood test for TTG IgA antibodies, taken while the person eats a regular gluten-containing diet, plus a total IgA measurement if IgA deficiency has not been checked before1. The total IgA measurement looks for IgA deficiency; if it is present, ACG says an IgG serology (commonly DGP and/or TTG) should be measured20.

An elevated TTG IgA leads to an upper endoscopy with biopsies of the duodenum19, and ACG recommends those biopsies to confirm the diagnosis in children and adults2. Even a negative blood test does not always end the work-up: ACG says that when the likelihood is high, endoscopy with biopsy should be considered despite negative serology21.

  • In children, ACG’s testing algorithm lists nonbiopsy criteria: a high TTG IgA (more than 10 times the upper limit of normal) with a positive endomysial antibody (EMA) in a second blood sample, only if the family agrees with a no-biopsy strategy22.
  • A genetic test looks for the DQ2 and DQ8 gene variants. NIDDK says that without them celiac disease is very unlikely23, but having them does not mean celiac disease, since most people with these variants do not develop it24.

NIDDK says doctors don’t recommend starting a gluten-free diet before diagnostic testing, because the diet can affect test results18. More on the blood work in our celiac blood test guide.

What wheat allergy testing looks for

Mayo Clinic lists a physical exam, a detailed medical history and some tests25. The NIAID-sponsored panel, writing about food allergy in general rather than wheat alone, says a thorough history is very important but cannot be diagnostic by itself29. Stanford’s allergy center names three tools for wheat allergy: skin prick tests, IgE antibody levels and oral food challenges3.

  • Skin prick test: tiny drops of purified allergen extracts, including wheat protein extracts, are pricked onto the skin, on the forearm or upper back26. The NIAID panel says a positive result correlates with IgE bound to skin mast cells, and recommends the test to identify foods that may provoke IgE-mediated reactions, but not as a diagnosis on its own31, 30.
  • Blood test for specific IgE: Mayo Clinic says it may be ordered when a skin condition or certain medicines prevent a skin test27. The NIAID panel says it detects allergic sensitization and is not diagnostic alone33, 32.
  • Oral food challenge: the suspected food is eaten under monitoring, starting with a small amount and increasing28. The NIAID panel calls the double-blind placebo-controlled version the gold standard4.

The word that matters is sensitization. FARE says a positive skin prick or IgE blood test can show the immune system recognizes a food without the person having symptoms, so these tests alone cannot confirm a food allergy34. The NIAID panel adds the other direction: negative skin tests occasionally occur in IgE-mediated food allergy, so a highly suggestive history calls for further evaluation, for example a physician-supervised food challenge35. It also recommends against routine total serum IgE for diagnosing food allergy36.

Because a challenge can trigger a reaction, FARE says it is typically performed by experienced allergists in medical facilities equipped to manage emergencies37.

Which test answers which question

Each test matched to the condition and the question it answers, as the sources state them
TestConditionWhat it answers
TTG IgA (with total IgA)Celiac diseaseWhether celiac antibodies are present; taken while eating gluten1
Duodenal biopsy at endoscopyCeliac diseaseThe confirming test in the ACG guideline2
DQ2 / DQ8 gene testCeliac diseaseNIDDK: without the variants celiac disease is very unlikely; having them does not mean celiac disease23, 24
Skin prick testWheat allergyWhether food-specific IgE is bound to skin mast cells (the NIAID panel writes about foods in general); not diagnostic alone31, 30
Wheat-specific IgE blood testWheat allergyWhether allergic sensitization is present (Mayo: a blood test screening for antibodies to common allergens, including wheat proteins27); not diagnostic alone33, 32
Supervised oral food challengeWheat allergyWhether eating the suspected food causes a reaction28; the NIAID panel calls the double-blind placebo-controlled version the gold standard4
Total serum IgEFood allergy in generalThe NIAID panel recommends against routine use for diagnosis36

Can a person have both?

GIG says a person can have a wheat allergy and also have celiac disease or non-celiac gluten sensitivity (NCGS)6. GIG also says that before NCGS can be diagnosed, celiac disease, wheat allergy and other possible causes must first be ruled out39; our celiac vs gluten intolerance guide covers that third condition.

Mayo Clinic adds that a person with wheat allergy might also be allergic to barley, oats and rye, and that unless other grains are involved, the wheat-free diet is less restrictive than a gluten-free diet40.

Who does which test, and what order the sources give

Both sources name history. NIDDK says doctors use medical and family history, a physical exam and test results, among other things, to look for signs that a person might have celiac disease and should be tested41; the NIAID panel says a thorough history is very important for focusing the food allergy work-up29.

After that the paths divide by specialty. GIG says a gastroenterologist usually diagnoses celiac disease and an allergist usually completes the testing for IgE food allergy12, 13. Mayo Clinic says a person may be referred to an allergist for certain diagnostic tests42. The GIG page does not give an order for running the celiac and allergy work-ups against each other44; that is a question for the treating clinician.

For the allergy visit, Mayo Clinic lists the kind of questions to expect, for example how soon after eating symptoms appear43.

What changes at the label and in the diet

The US 2004 allergen labeling law’s definition of a major food allergen lists wheat45. FARE says wheat must appear in plain language on packaged foods sold in the US, in the ingredient list or in a Contains statement46. Barley and rye are not in that definition45, but ACG describes celiac disease as a response to gluten in wheat, barley and rye7; see the Contains line and wheat, barley and rye.

The two diets are not the same list. FARE’s avoid list for wheat allergy names, among others, seitan, spelt, flour, semolina and wheat starch48. Mayo Clinic says gluten-free foods may also be free of grains a person with wheat allergy can eat, so sticking to them may needlessly limit the diet47. Our verdicts answer the gluten question, not the allergy question: see seitan, spelt, flour, bread and wheat starch, and wheat-free vs gluten-free labels.

FARE says it is important to work with a physician to determine an accurate diagnosis49.

Verdicts in this guide

Questions people ask

Can a celiac blood test detect wheat allergy?

The celiac blood test measures TTG IgA1, while wheat allergy involves IgE antibodies9. Stanford’s allergy center says celiac antibodies are IgA or IgG rather than IgE11.

Does a positive wheat IgE test mean a wheat allergy?

Not on its own: the NIAID panel says sIgE tests alone are not diagnostic of food allergy32, and FARE says a positive test can show sensitization without symptoms34.

Does going gluten-free first affect testing?

For celiac disease, NIDDK says it can: doctors don’t recommend starting a gluten-free diet before diagnostic testing because the diet can affect test results18.

Who performs an oral food challenge?

FARE says experienced allergists, typically in medical facilities equipped to manage emergencies37.

More in Celiac diagnosis, testing and gluten sensitivity

Sources