Gluten-free binders: what makers say about xanthan, guar, psyllium and flax

Short answer

It depends on the bag, and the maker’s own page settles it: Bob’s Red Mill says its 1-to-1 blend includes xanthan gum, while King Arthur sells its All-Purpose flour made without it10, 19. The Gluten Intolerance Group’s advice is that a blend with no xanthan gum or similar binding agent needs one added when baking3.

Published by Gluten Verdict · updated · 20 sources, each linked below

Four small jars of powders and seeds with spoons beside a red kitchen scale

Key points

  • Read the ingredient list, not the front of the bag: Bob’s Red Mill 1-to-1 and King Arthur Measure for Measure list xanthan gum, and King Arthur All-Purpose and Bob’s Red Mill All Purpose list none11, 17, 21, 14.
  • The Gluten Intolerance Group says “flours” often contain no binder while “baking mixes” do2.
  • Xanthan and guar are both sold by Bob’s Red Mill as binders for baking28, 32; Bob’s Red Mill’s xanthan page gives no per-cup amount30, and its guar page points to the package for instructions31.
  • Psyllium husk rests on less: no Bob’s Red Mill page for it was found, and the evidence here is a charity’s mention, one bread flour that lists a psyllium blend and one study48, 9, 25, 36.
  • Ground flax is described by its maker as a partial flour replacement and an egg replacer, not as a gum39, 40.

Does your bag already contain a binder?

The Gluten Intolerance Group (GIG) says some all-purpose gluten-free flours and baking mixes contain xanthan gum or a similar binding agent and some do not, and that these agents substitute for the gluten in wheat flour, which provides similar structure1.

GIG adds that “flours” often contain no binder while “baking mixes” do, and tells readers to read the ingredients2. Its advice for a blend with no binder is to add it when baking3, 4.

A 2019 review of natural hydrocolloids in gluten-free bread and cake reports that adding gums increased the volume and porosity of the breads and cakes and resulted in softer products35.

The ingredient list is the check. A gum can sit near the end of a long list: King Arthur’s Measure for Measure lists xanthan gum and cellulose gum after its vitamin and mineral blend17.

Six blends: the gum each lists and what the maker says

Each row below comes from the maker’s own product page or package, read on 2026-11-17. Package ingredient lists for King Arthur are on its package PDFs, not on the shop page.

Gum in the ingredient list and the maker’s statement on adding more
BlendGum in the ingredient listWhat the maker saysDate read
Bob’s Red Mill Gluten Free 1-to-1 Baking FlourXanthan gum, last in the list11“No specialty ingredients required”: the blend includes xanthan gum10. Replaces wheat flour cup for cup in non-yeast recipes122026-11-17
Bob’s Red Mill Gluten Free All Purpose Baking FlourNone: garbanzo bean flour, potato starch, tapioca flour, sorghum flour, fava bean flour14Made without xanthan gum or guar gum, and crafted for gluten free yeast breads13. The page names no gum to add and no amount152026-11-17
King Arthur Gluten-Free Measure for Measure FlourXanthan gum and cellulose gum17No need for additional specialty ingredients; best suited to non-yeasted recipes16. The package says it is not recommended as a 1:1 substitute for yeasted recipes182026-11-17
King Arthur Gluten-Free All-Purpose FlourNone listed21Made without xanthan gum so you can customize your recipes19. The page asks whether you have xanthan gum in your pantry and says many gluten-free recipes call for it20. Its package sandwich-bread recipe uses 1¼ teaspoons xanthan gum with 3 cups of the flour232026-11-17
King Arthur Gluten-Free Bread FlourXanthan gum, and a cellulose and psyllium fiber blend25Made with gluten-free wheat starch for yeasted recipes24. The package says to substitute 1:1 in bread recipes and add 2 to 3 tablespoons more liquid per cup of flour262026-11-17
Krusteaz Gluten Free All Purpose FlourXanthan gum, last in the list, with modified food starch listed as “food starch-modified”27The product page names xanthan gum only in its ingredient list and does not say to add a gum472026-11-17

Recipes and labels change, so the bag in your hand has the final word. Where we link a verdict, it records that product’s gluten status; this guide only reports its binders.

What xanthan, guar, psyllium and ground flax are each sold to do

Xanthan gum

Bob’s Red Mill sells xanthan gum as an essential ingredient for gluten free baking that acts as an emulsifier and a binder and adds volume to gluten free breads, cookies, cakes and other baked goods28. Its page says xanthan gum plays the crucial role of imitating gluten29.

GIG says xanthan gum is the result of bacterial fermentation of carbohydrates from various non-gluten sources8. One review describes it as completely soluble in both hot and cold water, imparting high solution viscosity at low concentrations33. Bob’s page gives no amount to add per cup of flour30.

Guar gum

Bob’s Red Mill sells guar gum for sauces and dressings, or as a binder and volume enhancer for baked goods32. Its page says to use small amounts and points to the package for instructions31.

GIG says guar gum comes from the guar bean seed8, and the 2019 review describes it as highly viscous at low concentrations, with thickening, stabilizing and water binding properties34. GIG groups guar with xanthan: both are commonly used in gluten-free baking for some of the properties gluten otherwise delivers, such as improved texture and elasticity7.

Psyllium husk

We found no Bob’s Red Mill product page for psyllium husk: its product sitemap lists none48. We did not read a psyllium product page from any other maker. What the sources we did read say is below.

GIG names psyllium husk, with chia seeds, as an alternative ingredient that offers some of the same characteristics as xanthan and guar9. King Arthur’s Gluten-Free Bread Flour lists a cellulose and psyllium fiber blend alongside xanthan gum25.

In one 2021 study of gluten-free bread, psyllium husk powder was tested at 2.86%, 7.14% and 17.14% of the flour weight36. The authors report that psyllium addition decreased crumb firmness values by 65–75% compared with the control gluten-free bread over 72 hours of storage37. That is one study with its own bread formula, not an amount to copy. The paper describes psyllium as a soluble fiber extracted from the husks of Plantago ovata seeds38.

Ground flax

Bob’s Red Mill’s golden flaxseed meal has one ingredient, whole golden flaxseed41. Among the baking uses its page lists: replace up to 25 percent of the flour with milled flaxseed in bread, pancakes, muffins and cookies39, or mix 2 tablespoons of ground flax with 3 tablespoons of water into a gel that replaces one egg40.

The page does not mention xanthan, guar, binders or gluten-free baking42, so we treat flax as a different ingredient, not a swap. GIG lists flax and chia among naturally gluten-free grains and flours43.

The four binders side by side
IngredientWhat it is, per the sourceWhat the source says it doesDate read
Xanthan gumResult of bacterial fermentation of carbohydrates from various non-gluten sources8Emulsifier and binder; adds volume to gluten free breads, cookies and cakes282026-11-17
Guar gumComes from the guar bean seed8Binder and volume enhancer for baked goods, in small amounts31, 322026-11-17
Psyllium huskA soluble fiber extracted from the husks of Plantago ovata seeds38Named by GIG as an alternative with some of the same characteristics9; tested in one study of gluten-free bread362026-11-17
Ground flaxWhole golden flaxseed, sold milled as meal41Among its listed uses: replaces up to 25 percent of the flour, or forms a gel that replaces one egg39, 402026-11-17

Which bakes the makers and GIG point each blend to

GIG says cookies, bars, quick breads, fruit cobblers, crisps and crumbles can generally be made with a straight substitution of a gluten-free flour blend5. Cakes and pie crusts are trickier, and GIG suggests a test run; bread recipes can be touchy, and GIG advises recipes developed specifically for gluten-free bread6.

What each maker’s own pages say about the bake
BakeBlend and what the maker says
Non-yeast: cookies, cakes, muffins, pancakesBob’s Red Mill 1-to-1 is for non-yeast recipes12; King Arthur Measure for Measure is best suited to non-yeasted recipes16.
Yeast breadBob’s Red Mill All Purpose is crafted for gluten free yeast breads13. King Arthur Bread Flour is made for yeasted recipes24. King Arthur says its All-Purpose flour is ideal for recipes calling for gluten-free flour, including yeasted recipes22, and that Measure for Measure is not recommended as a 1:1 swap for yeasted recipes18.

Homemade blends and amounts: what we could not source

GIG notes that not many years ago it was necessary to mix up your own blend, and that while this is still an option, many consumers appreciate the convenience of an all-purpose gluten-free flour that is ready to go46.

None of the maker or charity pages cited in this guide gives a general amount of gum per cup of flour. Bob’s xanthan page gives none30, and its guar page points to the package31. The one figure we found is King Arthur’s own package recipe for one loaf23, which is that recipe’s amount, not a rule. For a gum you buy, use the amount on its package or in a recipe written for your flour.

Label notes: wheat starch, seeds and cross-contact

King Arthur’s Gluten-Free Bread Flour is made with gluten-free wheat starch24, and its package ingredient line ends with “CONTAINS: Wheat”25. In the US, FDA’s definition of “gluten-free” allows an ingredient derived from a gluten-containing grain and processed to remove gluten, such as wheat starch, only if its use does not result in 20 parts per million or more gluten in the food44. Our King Arthur verdict covers these three flours.

Ground flax is milled flaxseed39, 41, and psyllium husk comes from Plantago ovata seeds38. GIG says seeds in their pure forms are gluten-free and that processed or flavored versions may have gluten-containing ingredients45. FDA notes that shared harvesting and transport equipment and storage silos often bring gluten-containing grains into contact with other grains, legumes and seeds that are naturally free of gluten49.

The Bob’s Red Mill flaxseed meal page shows a “Gluten free” badge among its certification badges but has no sentence about it42. For a flax or psyllium product with no gluten-free statement, the label and the maker are the place to ask.

A sheet to keep beside the flour bin

Print this page or copy the table. For each bag, copy the ingredient list from the package, then the maker’s own line on adding a gum, and the date you read it. Package wording can differ from a web page, so copy from the bag.

Flour-bin record
Flour on the shelfGum in the ingredient list (copy the word)Maker’s line on adding moreDate read
Bag 1: ________________________________
Bag 2: ________________________________
Bag 3: ________________________________
Bag 4: ________________________________

Verdicts in this guide

Questions people ask

Does gluten-free flour need xanthan gum?

It depends on the blend. GIG says some blends contain xanthan gum or a similar binder and some do not, and a blend without one needs it added1, 3. Bob’s Red Mill says its 1-to-1 blend includes xanthan gum10; King Arthur sells its All-Purpose flour made without it19.

Can guar gum replace xanthan gum?

GIG says both are commonly used in gluten-free baking for properties gluten otherwise delivers7, and Bob’s Red Mill sells both as binders28, 32. No page we read gives a swap amount; for guar, Bob’s points to the package31.

Is psyllium husk a substitute for xanthan gum?

GIG names psyllium husk as an alternative that offers some of the same characteristics9. The pages we read give no swap amount, and the one study we cite tested psyllium husk powder at three levels by flour weight in gluten-free bread36.

Is ground flax a binder?

Bob’s Red Mill describes ground flax as replacing up to 25 percent of the flour, and, mixed with water, as replacing one egg39, 40. Its page does not present flax as a gum replacement42.

More in Gluten-free baking technique

Sources