Egg and dairy substitutes in gluten-free baking: what each one does

Short answer

In most whole-egg recipes an egg binds, lifts and moistens a bake1, and King Arthur says there is no perfect replacement that meets all of an egg’s needs2. Work through it in this order:

  1. Find the job the egg does in your recipe. When you cannot tell, the University of Wyoming Extension says to assume it does all three jobs3.
  2. Match a substitute to that job: flax or chia gel binds but does not build structure4, fruit purée adds moisture5, and one maker says its replacer powder can be used in cakes, cookies, muffins, pancakes and quick breads6.
  3. For milk and butter, King Arthur says to use a plant-based milk and notes vegan butter is almost indistinguishable from butter in most recipes7, 8; expect differences in custards and cream fillings9.
  4. Check each substitute’s own label: on a food FDA regulates, a gluten-free claim means less than 20 parts per million of gluten10.

Published by Gluten Verdict · updated · 10 sources, each linked below

Bowl of flax gel with a whisk beside an applesauce jar and a red stand mixer

Key points

  • King Arthur says eggs usually play a major structure-building role in gluten-free recipes, and recommends recipes written without eggs before trying to replace them11.
  • Choose a substitute by the job it covers, because nothing replaces everything an egg does2.
  • Makers give different flax amounts per egg: Bob’s Red Mill says 2 tablespoons of ground flax to 3 tablespoons of water12, King Arthur says 1 tablespoon to 3 tablespoons13.
  • King Arthur says soy milk equals dairy milk in protein level, an area where most other vegan milks fall far short14.
  • A gluten-free claim means less than 20 parts per million on a food FDA regulates10; read each substitute’s own label.

What is the egg doing in your recipe?

The University of Wyoming Extension says eggs contribute to the consistency, color, flavor and structure of baked goods15. King Arthur lists structure, emulsifying, binding and leavening16. Three of those jobs decide which substitute fits:

  • Lift: eggs trap pockets of air that expand as they heat17.
  • Binding: eggs help combine ingredients and hold them together18.
  • Moisture: the liquid from eggs is absorbed by the other ingredients and helps keep the finished product moist19.

Yolk and white do different work. The extension says the yolk is fatty and helps bind, while the white provides leavening and moisture, and that in most whole-egg recipes the egg does all three jobs1.

Clues for reading your recipe

The extension gives rules of thumb. If the recipe has no baking powder or baking soda, assume the egg is the leavener; a recipe that calls only for whites most likely uses them to lift and moisten; one that calls only for yolks uses them to bind20. If you cannot tell, it advises assuming all three jobs and choosing a substitute, or a combination, that covers them3.

The number of eggs matters too: the fewer eggs a recipe calls for, the easier they are to substitute21. King Arthur says an egg-heavy recipe, such as a soufflé or quiche, is nearly impossible to pull off without eggs22.

Why gluten-free batters make egg swaps harder

King Arthur says skipping eggs in gluten-free baking can often be a challenge, because eggs usually play a major structure-building role in gluten-free recipes. Its advice is to bake gluten-free recipes that do not include eggs to begin with, rather than replace them11.

It has had some success with a flax egg in some gluten-free recipes, and its Gluten-Free Sandwich Bread recipe carries a tip for an egg-free version made with flax23.

Binding is the other half of the problem. The Gluten Intolerance Group notes that a gluten-free flour without xanthan gum or another binding agent needs one added24. Our guide to xanthan gum, guar gum, psyllium and flax covers those binders, and gluten-free baking troubleshooting is the place to start when a bake has failed.

Egg substitutes, by the job they do

Amounts are per egg, as each source gives them. Treat each row as a starting point and test it in your own gluten-free batter.

Egg substitutes as makers and baking authorities describe them
SubstituteAmount per egg, as the source gives itWhat the source says it does
Flax or chia gel1 tablespoon flax meal or whole chia seeds with 3 tablespoons water, rested 5 to 10 minutes13. Bob’s Red Mill gives 2 tablespoons ground flax to 3 tablespoons water12.Adds body and helps bind but does not build structure, so it is not ideal for light, fluffy cakes4.
Fruit purée: banana, pumpkin, applesauce1/4 cup of mashed banana, pumpkin purée or applesauce, or a similar purée such as sweet potato25.Adds a lot of moistness5. Can make cookies cakey and cakes or muffins denser26.
Plain Greek yogurt (a dairy ingredient)1/4 cup27.Adds moisture and tenderness28. Not for vegan baking, and large amounts can add gumminess29.
Aquafaba, the liquid from canned chickpeas2 tablespoons for about 1 egg white; 1/4 cup for about 1 whole egg30.Too delicate for baked goods that rely on whipped eggs or whites for structure, such as angel food cake, chiffon cake or macarons31.
Starch slurry2 tablespoons cornstarch, arrowroot powder, potato starch or tapioca starch with 3 tablespoons water32.King Arthur calls it less reliable than the options listed above it on its page33.
Lift without an egg1/4 cup carbonated water; or 2 tablespoons water, 1 tablespoon oil and 2 teaspoons baking powder; or 1 tablespoon vinegar and 1 teaspoon baking soda; or 2 tablespoons lemon juice and 1 teaspoon baking soda34.The extension’s suggestions for a recipe where the egg acts as the leavening agent34.

When you are unsure which job the egg has, the extension suggests combining substitutes, for example carbonated water for lift and a chia gel for binding35.

What a ready-made egg replacer powder is, and is not

King Arthur notes that commercial egg replacers are all different36, and says to follow the measurements and instructions on the product package37.

Bob’s Red Mill’s Gluten Free Egg Replacer lists four ingredients, potato starch, tapioca flour, baking soda and psyllium husk fiber, with no grains, soy, gluten or beans38. The maker says it can be used in cakes, cookies, muffins, pancakes and quick breads6, and that you add water in varying amounts depending on whether you are replacing a white, a yolk or a whole egg39.

The maker also says not to try to scramble it or make an egg white meringue40. Other brands differ, so read each one’s own ingredient list and label.

What milk, butter and cream do, and what replaces them

King Arthur says the protein, fat and sugar in milk can affect a baked good’s structure, mouthfeel, flavor and browning, sometimes barely and sometimes a lot41. Soy milk matches dairy milk at 8 grams of protein per 8-ounce serving, and most other plant milks fall far short14.

In King Arthur’s tests, all the milks performed well in a yeast bread. Soy gave the loaf closest to the dairy one, while the other plant milks produced bread that rose higher42 but was prone to crumbling43. In basic muffins, rise, texture, mouthfeel, flavor and browning were the same across the milks44.

Custards and cream fillings were where the milks differed. Only soy milk came close to the dairy version’s set, with oat milk second9. Coconut milk thickened and then fell apart as it cooled, and almond milk never thickened45. Treat these results as a starting point in a gluten-free batter.

Buttermilk, cream and butter

  • Buttermilk: stir 1 tablespoon lemon juice or white vinegar into 1 cup of plant milk46.
  • Heavy cream: use full-fat (not “lite”) canned coconut milk, or canned unsweetened coconut cream47.
  • Butter: King Arthur found vegan butter almost indistinguishable from butter in most recipes8. In its gluten-free chocolate chip cookie test, the vegan butter cookies were a bit cakier and less chewy than the butter ones48.

For a dairy-free fat in gluten-free baking, King Arthur suggests choosing the fat that most resembles the one in the original recipe49, and warns that the result will not necessarily be the same50. Its general rule for dairy-free baking is that the fewer adjustments you make to a recipe, the more likely it is to turn out as expected51.

Checking each substitute’s gluten-free status

A substitute can be gluten-free in its plain form and still need a label check in the version you buy. On a food FDA regulates, “gluten-free” is a voluntary claim a maker may choose to use52, and the labels “gluten-free,” “no gluten,” “free of gluten” and “without gluten” all mean less than 20 parts per million of gluten10.

Our verdicts cover most of the ingredients named here. Each shows what makers’ own pages and labels said, with the date we read them:

Our oat milk verdict says the answer depends on the brand, and our rice milk verdict says the carton decides, so read the carton before it goes in the batter. For a replacer powder, read that product’s own page: Bob’s Red Mill’s lists its four ingredients and says no gluten38. Flax meal and aquafaba from a can have no verdict of ours yet, so read their labels too.

Verdicts in this guide

Questions people ask

Can I use a flax egg in a gluten-free cake?

King Arthur says flax and chia eggs add body and help bind but do not build structure, so they are not ideal for light, fluffy cakes4. It has had some success with flax in some gluten-free recipes, such as its sandwich bread23.

Is it better to replace the egg or choose an egg-free recipe?

King Arthur recommends baking gluten-free recipes that do not include eggs to begin with, instead of trying to replace them11.

Can I swap plant milk for milk in a gluten-free recipe?

King Arthur says to use your favorite plant-based milk where a recipe calls for milk7. Custards and cream fillings are where its tests found the milks differ9.

Is an egg replacer powder gluten-free?

It depends on the brand. Bob’s Red Mill’s lists potato starch, tapioca flour, baking soda and psyllium husk fiber, with no grains or gluten38. For any other brand, a gluten-free claim on an FDA-regulated food means less than 20 parts per million10.

More in Gluten-free baking technique

Sources