Can non-celiac gluten sensitivity go away? What the trials show and do not show

Short answer

No source we read says whether non-celiac gluten sensitivity (NCGS) goes away. The Gluten Intolerance Group lists whether you need to stay gluten-free for life as still unknown1, and the Salerno experts’ criteria say NCGS may be transient, so gluten tolerance needs to be re-assessed2. Celiac disease is a different case: the American College of Gastroenterology defines it as permanent3.

Published by Gluten Verdict · updated · 13 sources, each linked below

Reviewed by Mark Peter, Registered dietitian (RD), on

Notebook, pencil and lime-green mug on a kitchen table in morning light.

Key points

  • The Gluten Intolerance Group lists whether you need to stay gluten-free for life as something still unknown1, and Coeliac UK calls NCGS a new area that needs more research4.
  • The Salerno experts say NCGS may be transient and that gluten tolerance needs to be re-assessed, which is a reason to ask, not a finding that it fades2.
  • One follow-up of 44 people, assessed after at least one year, found symptoms reduced, though a significant proportion still reported symptoms5, 6.
  • Challenge trials disagree: gluten-specific effects in 8% of participants in one7, symptom recurrence in one-third in another8, and worse scores after fructans than gluten in a third9.
  • Coeliac UK and GIG both say celiac testing may be inaccurate once gluten is out of the diet, so the order of steps matters10, 11.

Why celiac disease and wheat allergy come first

The Salerno experts’ criteria describe NCGS as a syndrome of intestinal and extra-intestinal symptoms related to eating gluten-containing food, in people who have neither celiac disease nor wheat allergy12. GIG says it is diagnosed by ruling out celiac disease and wheat allergy, and that there are no tests or biomarkers for it13.

Celiac disease is a separate condition: the American College of Gastroenterology defines it as a permanent immune-mediated response to gluten present in wheat, barley and rye3. Coeliac UK describes wheat allergy as a reaction to proteins found in wheat, triggered by the immune system, that usually occurs within seconds or minutes of eating14.

The order matters for this question. Coeliac UK does not recommend trying a gluten-free diet as a first option, because it could prevent a celiac test from giving an accurate result10, and says it is essential to keep eating gluten for the tests to work15. GIG says testing may not be accurate if you are already on a gluten-free diet11.

Whether celiac disease was properly excluded is a question for the clinician who ordered the tests. Our guide to the celiac gluten challenge covers testing after a gluten-free period.

What “go away” would have to mean

The question can mean three different things, and the evidence differs for each.

Three meanings of “go away”
If “go away” means…What would show itWhat the sources say
Symptoms ease while you stay gluten-freeFollow-up of diagnosed people over timeOne follow-up of 44 people, assessed after at least one year, found symptoms reduced, with persistent mild symptoms still reported by a significant proportion5, 6, 37. Its authors write that earlier outcome information came from studies of the first few weeks of treatment16.
Gluten can come back into the diet without symptomsA repeat, blinded challenge in the same people after a period gluten-freeThe Salerno experts say it is unknown whether long-term, strict avoidance of all gluten-related products is necessary, and that NCGS may be transient2. GIG lists the same question as unknown1.
Gluten was never the triggerBlinded challenges that separate gluten from other wheat components and from placeboTrials point different ways; the next two sections set them out.

Nothing here shows that the sensitivity fades, and nothing shows that it does not. Coeliac UK calls NCGS a new area and says more research is needed to understand the condition and who is at risk4.

What the challenge trials found

These trials ask a narrower question than the one in the title: when gluten is added back to the diet, do symptoms return, and are they specific to gluten? The table gives what each abstract reports.

Four challenge trials, as their abstracts report them
TrialWho took partWhat they were givenWhat the abstract reports
Biesiekierski et al., 201134 people who completed the trial, with irritable bowel syndrome, celiac disease excluded, symptoms controlled on a gluten-free diet17, 18Gluten (two bread slices and one muffin a day) or placebo, for up to 6 weeks1813 of 19 people (68%) on gluten and 6 of 15 (40%) on placebo reported symptoms were not adequately controlled19
Biesiekierski et al., 201337 people with NCGS and irritable bowel syndrome, no celiac disease20A 2-week reduced-FODMAP diet, then 1 week each of high-gluten (16 g a day), low-gluten (2 g) or control diets; 22 people then had a 3-day rechallenge20, 21Symptoms improved on reduced FODMAPs and worsened to a similar degree with gluten or whey protein; gluten-specific effects in 8% of participants7
Zanini et al., 201535 people without celiac disease, on a gluten-free diet22Gluten-containing or gluten-free flour for 10 days, a 2-week washout, then the other flour2212 people (34%) correctly identified the gluten-containing flour and were classed as having NCGS; 17 (49%) wrongly thought the gluten-free flour contained gluten23, 24
Skodje et al., 201859 people on a self-instituted gluten-free diet, celiac disease excluded25Gluten (5.7 g), fructans (2.1 g) or placebo in muesli bars, 7 days each26Overall symptom scores were higher after fructans than after gluten9, with no difference between gluten and placebo27

Reviewers give reasons for the mixed picture. Khan, Suarez and Murray write that existing studies have variable results, likely because of the lack of a uniform diagnostic criterion, dependence on patients’ perception of symptoms and a large nocebo effect28. The Salerno experts say gluten challenges may need to be repeated to offset the strong nocebo effect often seen in these patients29.

Our reading of the table: the challenge periods are days to weeks, so these trials speak to whether gluten brings symptoms back in the short term, not to how the condition runs over years.

FODMAPs, fructans and other possible triggers

Coeliac UK notes some debate about whether gluten or other components cause the sensitivity, and that components such as FODMAPs and other non-gluten proteins in wheat leave the diet when gluten-containing ingredients do30. The Salerno experts say the offending dietary protein has not been identified and could include components other than gluten, such as amylase-trypsin inhibitors31. The Celiac Disease Foundation says research has not confirmed that gluten is the culprit triggering the immune reaction32.

GIG gives one route: wheat contains fructans, as do some foods without gluten such as onion and watermelon, so a diet that eliminates wheat could reduce fructan intake and, if fructans are the issue, relieve symptoms33. It adds that some experts do not agree that gluten causes the reactions, at least in some individuals34.

GIG’s page on the low FODMAP diet says it is not meant to be followed indefinitely and is designed for short-term symptom relief and to identify specific trigger foods35. It says there is no laboratory test for FODMAP intolerance, so an elimination diet should be done under the guidance of a Registered Dietitian or another healthcare professional36. Our guide to gluten-free and low FODMAP goes further.

What long-term follow-up exists

We found two follow-up reports. We read their PubMed abstracts, not the full papers.

Tovoli and colleagues studied 44 people with non-celiac wheat sensitivity diagnosed by the Salerno criteria, comparing symptoms before the gluten-free diet with a follow-up after at least one year5. The prevalence and severity of the most common symptoms fell, but mild intestinal and extra-intestinal symptoms persisted in 65.9% and 72.7% of them37. The authors conclude that a significant proportion still report symptoms, though attenuated, even years after diagnosis6.

Barmeyer and colleagues used response to a gluten-free diet as the reference test for wheat sensitivity in people with diarrhea-dominant or mixed-type irritable bowel syndrome38: 12 of the 35 who finished (34%) were classified as responders39. At one year, all responders and 55% of non-responders were still on the diet and reported symptom relief40. The record states the study was supported by a grant from Dr. Schär AG41.

Both reports describe people who followed the diet. Staying on a diet is not the same as needing it, and neither abstract reports gluten being added back years later.

Reintroducing gluten: what the sources describe

The Salerno criteria are a protocol for clinicians. They describe a double-blind, placebo-controlled challenge of 8 g of gluten a day: one week of challenge, a one-week strict gluten-free washout, then a crossover to the second week42. For people already gluten-free when first seen at a specialty clinic, the experts say a shortened procedure that keeps only the challenge step may be adopted43.

Khan, Suarez and Murray write that a single-blind placebo-controlled rechallenge has been recommended for diagnosis in clinical practice44, and that a team approach involving the primary care doctor, gastroenterologist, pathologist and nutritionist is important45. GIG’s low FODMAP page says NCGS is diagnosed through a gluten elimination and challenge process rather than lab tests46.

Coeliac UK says that after a negative celiac test, with other causes ruled out, a person might wish to discuss the possibility of NCGS with their healthcare team47. Its page gives no steps for reintroducing gluten48. Khan, Suarez and Murray also write that patients should be educated on the nutritional implications of a long-term gluten-free diet49.

Questions to bring to the appointment

These questions are ours, not taken from a source. They are prompts for a conversation, not medical advice.

  • Was celiac disease excluded while I was eating gluten, and was wheat allergy ruled out?
  • If I want to find out whether gluten still affects me, should that be a blinded challenge, and who would supervise it?
  • Could a dietitian-led FODMAP plan help sort out which parts of wheat matter?
  • What should be planned for nutrition during a long gluten-free period?

Questions people ask

Can you outgrow non-celiac gluten sensitivity?

The sources we read do not say. GIG lists whether you need to stay gluten-free for life as unknown1, and the Salerno criteria say NCGS may be transient2.

Is it the same as celiac disease?

No. The American College of Gastroenterology defines celiac disease as a permanent immune-mediated response to gluten3. Coeliac UK says that in NCGS it is not clear how the immune system might be involved, because no antibodies are produced and there does not appear to be damage to the gut lining50. See celiac disease vs gluten intolerance.

Is it gluten that causes the symptoms?

The trials disagree. One found symptoms not adequately controlled in more people on gluten than on placebo19; another found no difference between gluten and placebo27. The Celiac Disease Foundation says research has not confirmed that gluten is the culprit triggering the immune reaction32.

Can I find out by eating gluten again?

That is a question for your clinician. The sources we read describe challenges run as structured protocols, with a placebo and a washout42, and Coeliac UK’s page gives no steps for doing it yourself48.

More in Celiac diagnosis, testing and gluten sensitivity

Sources