Reading a US label for gluten and another food allergy

Short answer

A US label needs two reads, because allergen law and the gluten-free rule are separate: the ingredient list or Contains line has to name each major allergen used to make the food2, 3, while “gluten-free” is a voluntary claim that has to meet FDA’s rule, which sets a limit below 20 parts per million of gluten29, 27.

  1. Read the ingredient list and Contains line for your second allergen: each of the nine major allergens used to make the food has to be named in one of them1, 2, 3.
  2. Read the gluten-free claim for gluten, or the whole ingredient list when there is none, because barley and rye are not among the allergens a Contains line has to list1, 35.
  3. Do not take a gluten-free claim as proof a food has no wheat: a food may contain an ingredient made from wheat and processed to remove gluten, and a label that names wheat then needs an asterisk statement27, 28.
  4. Treat may-contain and shared-facility lines as the maker’s voluntary statements about cross-contact; allergen law does not address them8, 38.

Published by Gluten Verdict · updated · 18 sources, each linked below

Reviewed by Mark Peter, Registered dietitian (RD), on

Shopper's shoulder in a store aisle with a red basket and a box held up

Key points

  • Allergen labeling names nine major allergens; the gluten-free claim is voluntary and means under 20 ppm of gluten1, 29, 27.
  • Barley and rye are not among the allergens a Contains line has to list, so a Contains line without wheat does not clear a food for gluten1, 35.
  • A gluten-free food can contain an ingredient made from wheat and processed to remove gluten; if the label names wheat, it needs an asterisk statement27, 28.
  • Coconut is no longer a major allergen in FDA’s view, and highly refined oils are exempt from allergen labeling18, 14.
  • No regulation defines “egg-free” or “peanut-free” the way FDA’s rule defines “gluten-free”9, 27.

Two label systems, side by side

A US package can carry two separate kinds of statement. Allergen labeling is required of FDA-regulated foods that contain a major allergen2, 7. A gluten-free claim is something a maker may add, and FDA’s rule sets what it has to mean29. Each answers a different question.

Allergen labeling and the gluten-free claim compared
QuestionAllergen labelingGluten-free claim
Is it required?Yes: the label has to name the food source of each major food allergen used to make the food2No: the rule covers the voluntary use of the claim29
How much is too much?FDA has not established a threshold level for any allergens6Below 20 parts per million of gluten, including any unavoidable gluten27
Which grains?Wheat is a major allergen1; barley and rye are not among the allergens required to be listed35Wheat, rye, barley and their crossbred hybrids count as gluten-containing grains26
Where is it on the package?In the ingredient list or in a Contains statement3No set place: the rule does not require a specific location on the label34
What does “free” mean?For a claim such as “egg-free”, no regulation defines the conditions9“Gluten-free”, “free of gluten”, “without gluten” and “no gluten” all have to meet the rule30
May-contain linesFDA’s allergen labeling provision does not address them8Not prohibited on a food that also says gluten-free, if truthful and not misleading31

The nine major allergens and what the label must name

FDA’s list of major food allergens is milk, eggs, fish, Crustacean shellfish, tree nuts, peanuts, wheat, soybeans and sesame1. Each has to be named in one of two ways: in parentheses after the ingredient it comes from, or in a Contains statement next to the ingredient list3. Fish, shellfish and tree nuts are named by type or species5.

What each allergen line names, and the edge that matters if you also avoid gluten
AllergenWhat the label namesEdge for a gluten-free reader
Wheat“Wheat”; FDA defines it as any species in the genus Triticum and lists grains such as spelt and triticale11Barley and rye are gluten grains26 but not on the Contains line’s list35
Milk“Milk”; FDA reads milk as milk from domesticated cows, goats, sheep or other ruminants19Milk from animals other than cows should carry the animal’s name, such as “goat milk”20
Egg“Egg”; FDA reads eggs as eggs from domesticated chickens, ducks, geese, quail and other fowl19Plain eggs and egg noodles differ for gluten: see our verdicts on eggs and egg noodles
Soy“Soy” or “soybeans”; inside another ingredient it shows as, for example, “lecithin (soy)”4Soy sauce made from soybeans and wheat names two allergens32: see the soy section below
Peanut“Peanuts”, in the ingredient list or the Contains line3A highly refined oil made from a major allergen is exempt, while one that is not highly refined has to be declared14, 15; see peanut oil
Tree nutsThe specific nut, such as almond, pecan or walnut5Only the nuts on FDA’s Table 1 must meet the allergen rule12; coconut is no longer on it18
Sesame“Sesame”, on packaged foods and dietary supplements since January 1, 202322Products already on shelves before 2023 did not have to be removed23

Wheat allergy and celiac disease read different labels

The Gluten Intolerance Group says celiac disease is an autoimmune condition, while wheat allergy involves an immune response that is not autoimmune36. Its bulletin adds that a person with a wheat allergy must avoid any form of wheat but does not have trouble tolerating gluten from non-wheat sources, and that a person can have a wheat allergy and also celiac disease or non-celiac gluten sensitivity37. On a label, that splits the two questions:

  • For wheat: the allergen label names wheat, a term FDA applies to grains such as spelt and triticale11. A gluten-free claim does not rule wheat out. The rule allows an ingredient made from a gluten grain and processed to remove gluten, with wheat starch as its own example, if the food stays under 20 ppm27. When such a food names wheat in its ingredient list or Contains line, the label has to put an asterisk after “wheat” and carry the statement “The wheat has been processed to allow this food to meet the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) requirements for gluten-free foods.”28
  • For gluten: the Contains line is not required to list barley or rye35, so a gluten-free claim, or a read of the full ingredient list when there is none, has to carry that question. Our guides on reading a food label and on the Contains line, wheat, barley and rye go through it.

Soy: soy sauce, tamari and lecithin

Soy sauce is where the two questions meet most often. FDA says soy sauce is ordinarily made by fermenting soybeans and wheat, that some are made without wheat, and that in general one made from soybeans and wheat may not bear a “gluten-free” claim32. Kikkoman’s page for its regular soy sauce lists water, soybeans, wheat and salt41, so that bottle names two major allergens.

Kikkoman’s gluten-free tamari lists water, soybeans, salt and sugar and says it is certified gluten-free by the Gluten Intolerance Group42. The wheat is gone from that list; the soybeans are not.

Soy inside another ingredient can be shown in parentheses after it, as in “lecithin (soy)”4. Whether soy lecithin carries gluten is a separate question that our soy lecithin entry takes up. For other soy-based foods, each verdict shows what our sources say about gluten: teriyaki sauce, hoisin sauce, oyster sauce, miso, tofu, edamame, soy milk, soy flour and soy sauce itself.

Peanut and tree nuts: flours, milks, coconut and oils

Peanuts and tree nuts are two separate allergens on the list1. For tree nuts, FDA’s guidance names the nuts that count in its Table 1: almond, black walnut, Brazil nut, California walnut, cashew, filbert/hazelnut, heartnut/Japanese walnut, macadamia nut/bush nut, pecan, pine nut/pinon nut, pistachio and walnut13. Only those must meet the allergen labeling requirements12.

Coconut is not on that list: FDA says it no longer considers coconut a major food allergen18. A product that uses a Contains statement would not name coconut there, but coconut still has to appear in the ingredient list unless an exemption applies17. Our verdicts cover coconut flour and coconut milk for gluten.

Nut flours and nut milks are two places where a gluten-free kitchen can add a tree nut. Blue Diamond’s almond flour page says the flour is made with California grown almonds and calls it gluten-free49; almond is on Table 113. Almond Breeze’s page describes its original almondmilk as an alternative to dairy and soymilks and says it is made with real California almonds50. A swap away from milk or soy can therefore be a swap onto a tree nut13, 50. See our verdicts on almond flour, almond milk, cashew milk and macadamia milk.

Oils follow a special rule. A highly refined oil made from a major allergen is exempt from the allergen labeling rule, but, under FDA’s general ingredient rules, the oil’s source goes in its name in the ingredient list, as in “soybean oil”14. An oil that is not highly refined has to be declared15. Our entries for peanut oil, walnut oil, peanut butter and Nutella cover their gluten side.

Egg and milk: what gluten-free mixes ask you to add

A gluten-free mix can list no egg or milk and still call for them. Bob’s Red Mill’s Gluten Free Pancake Mix page says to “just add milk or water, butter or oil, and an egg”44, though the ingredient list on the page names neither egg nor milk45. Its Gluten Free Brownie Mix page says “All you need from your kitchen is 3 eggs, 1/2 cup butter, 1/4 cup water and our gluten free brownie mix”46, again with no egg or milk in the mix’s own ingredient list47. The ingredient list describes the mix; the directions add the allergens.

For milk and egg as ingredients, FDA reads “milk” as milk from domesticated cows, goats, sheep or other ruminants and “eggs” as eggs from domesticated chickens, ducks, geese, quail and other fowl19. For foods with egg as an ingredient, our verdicts on mayonnaise and egg noodles show where the gluten question sits.

Sesame: what changed on labels

As of January 1, 2023, sesame must be labeled as an allergen on packaged foods and dietary supplements22. Products already on their way to or on shelves before 2023 did not have to come off the market23. FDA says that during the transition you may still find products for sale that do not list sesame as an allergen on the label53. FDA also says some manufacturers changed their recipes after the FASTER Act, and there are now products with small amounts of sesame that did not have it before24. For a product with an unclear label, FDA’s advice to people allergic to sesame is to contact the manufacturer or supplier25.

May-contain and free-from lines when you have two questions

Both questions send you to the same part of the package. FARE says advisory labeling is voluntary and that no law governs when to use it or how to word it38.

What FDA says about advisory and free-from statements
Statement on the labelWhat FDA says
“May contain [allergen]” or “made in a facility that also uses [allergen]”The allergen labeling provision does not address advisory statements; they must be truthful and not misleading8
“Made in a facility that also processes wheat” on a gluten-free foodThe gluten-free rule does not prohibit it, if truthful and not misleading31
“Contains milk” plus “may contain milk”Not appropriate: an advisory statement for a major allergen already declared as an ingredient10
“Wheat-free” plus “may contain wheat”Not appropriate for the same allergen21
“Egg-free”, “peanut-free”, “milk-free”No regulation defines the conditions for a “free” claim from a major allergen9

Where it is unclear whether a product could have come in contact with an allergen, FARE’s advice is to call the manufacturer39.

Our guide on may-contain wheat labels takes up the gluten side of these lines.

Where the Contains line does not apply

FDA enforces the allergen provisions on most packaged foods, but not on meat, poultry and egg products (USDA), alcoholic beverages under TTB labeling rules, raw agricultural commodities, highly refined oils, or most foods sold at retail or food service that are not pre-packaged with a label7. The labeling requirements do not apply to foods put in a wrapper or box in response to a customer’s order, such as a sandwich prepared to order16. The gluten-free rule has a similar split: it does not apply to foods whose labeling USDA or TTB regulates33.

What makers say on both questions

These are statements from the maker’s own page, read on 2026-11-17. A maker’s page can change, and the package in your hand has the final word; FARE notes that ingredients and manufacturing processes can change without warning40.

Maker statements on gluten and a second allergen
ProductWhat it says on glutenWhat it says on another allergen
Kikkoman Gluten-Free Tamari Soy SauceCertified gluten-free by the Gluten Intolerance Group42Brewed from water, soybeans, salt and sugar, so soy is still named42
Kikkoman Soy Sauce (all-purpose)Brewed from water, soybeans, wheat and salt41Kikkoman says the all-purpose and less sodium soy sauces are brewed at its Walworth, WI plant, where no peanut or tree nut ingredients enter, and to check the back of the label for where a specific product was made43
Enjoy Life Semi-Sweet Mini ChipsSays all its chocolate is free from gluten and 14 common allergens52Lists “Our chocolate is free from: Wheat, Lupin, Casein, Crustaceans, Mustard, Dairy, Shellfish, Sesame, Tree nuts, Fish, Egg, Peanut, Added sulfites, and Soy.”51
Bob’s Red Mill Organic Coconut FlourSays it is tested and confirmed gluten free and packaged in a separate gluten free facility48Coconut is no longer a major allergen in FDA’s view18
Blue Diamond Almond FlourCalls the flour gluten-free49Made with California grown almonds49, a nut on FDA’s Table 113

Verdicts in this guide

Questions people ask

Does a gluten-free label mean the food has no wheat?

Not necessarily. FDA’s rule allows an ingredient derived from a gluten grain and processed to remove gluten, such as wheat starch, if the food stays under 20 ppm27. If the label then names wheat, it has to carry the asterisk statement that the wheat has been processed28.

Will barley or rye appear on a Contains line?

FDA’s list of major allergens does not include barley or rye1. The Celiac Disease Foundation says barley and rye are not among the allergens required to be listed35.

Is coconut a tree nut on US labels?

FDA says it no longer considers coconut a major food allergen18. Coconut still has to be in the ingredient list when it is an ingredient, unless an exemption applies17.

Are “egg-free” and “milk-free” defined like “gluten-free”?

FDA says there are no regulations defining specific conditions for a “free” claim from a major food allergen source9. “Gluten-free” has its own rule, with a 20 ppm limit27.

Does highly refined peanut or soybean oil have to be declared as an allergen?

A highly refined oil made from a major allergen is exempt from the allergen labeling rule, but in general the source stays in the oil’s name in the ingredient list14.

More in Nutrition and combining diets

Sources