Gluten-removed beer: what the treatment does, why the tests are disputed and what the TTB statement says

Short answer

Gluten-removed beer is regular beer brewed from a gluten grain and then treated, for example with an enzyme, to remove gluten1, 14. TTB allows the label to say so only with a qualifying statement beside the claim that includes “The gluten content of this product cannot be verified, and this product may contain gluten.”2 The National Celiac Association says gluten reduced beers should be avoided by those following a gluten-free diet3.

Published by Gluten Verdict · updated · 9 sources, each linked below

Brown bottle and half-poured glass on a turquoise bar mat.

Key points

  • GIG describes gluten-free stouts as brewed from gluten-free grains such as sorghum, rice or millet4, and FDA says beer made from gluten-containing grains processed to remove gluten before fermentation may also bear the term if it meets the requirements35; GIG describes a gluten-removed beer as a regular beer that has undergone a process to reduce gluten content5.
  • FDA does not consider fermentation or hydrolysis a process that removes gluten, and says conventional methods may not accurately detect and quantify gluten in fermented foods6, 7.
  • TTB agrees with FDA that there is currently no scientifically valid method to quantify gluten in fermented or hydrolyzed foods as intact gluten protein8, and TTB will consider a label statement of a specific level such as “contains x ppm” misleading without an appropriate basis or necessary qualification9.
  • In one published study, mass spectrometry found gluten peptides in many gluten-reduced beers10; in another, gluten composition varied between three replicate pilot-scale productions11.
  • NCA and GIG both treat gluten-removed beer differently from labeled gluten-free beer3, 12, 16.

Gluten-free beer and gluten-removed beer are two different products

The Gluten Intolerance Group (GIG) says gluten-free stouts are brewed using gluten-free grains and names sorghum, rice and millet as examples4. FDA also says a beer made from gluten-containing grains that were processed to remove gluten before fermentation may bear the term gluten-free if it meets the requirements35. GIG describes gluten-removed beer, using stout as its example, as regular beer that has undergone a process to reduce gluten content5.

FDA says beer is a fermented beverage derived from malted cereal grains, most commonly barley or wheat, which are gluten-containing grains13. Which agency writes the label rules depends on the beer: FDA says beers that meet the Federal Alcohol Administration Act definition of malt beverages are subject to TTB’s labeling requirements, while certain other beers, such as sorghum beer, fall under FDA’s13.

How the two kinds of beer compare
Gluten-free beerGluten-removed beer
Brewed fromGluten-free grains such as sorghum, rice or millet, in GIG’s description4; FDA also allows the claim on a beer from gluten-containing grains processed to remove gluten before fermentation, if the requirements are met35A gluten-containing grain, then treated; TTB’s wording covers products fermented from one or more ingredients that are, or are derived from, a gluten-containing grain14
Wording TTB allows“gluten-free”, where the product would be entitled to the claim under FDA’s standards15A statement that it was processed, treated or crafted to remove gluten14, with a qualifying statement beside it2
NCA’s positionLists labeled gluten-free beer made without malted barley as considered gluten-free16Says gluten reduced beers should be avoided by those following a gluten-free diet3

Our beer verdict records what the sources we read say about beer in general; this guide is about the narrower question of the gluten-removed label.

What an enzyme treatment does to a barley beer

Colgrave and colleagues write that gluten fragments persist in conventional beers, and that barley-based beers crafted to remove gluten use proprietary precipitation and/or application of enzymes, for example prolyl endopeptidases (PEP) that degrade the proline-rich gluten molecules1.

FDA defines a hydrolyzed food as one whose proteins and other components are broken into smaller compounds by reaction with water, and notes that enzymes often accelerate these reactions17. Breaking gluten into fragments is therefore not the same as taking it out: FDA does not consider hydrolysis7, or fermentation6, a process to remove gluten.

One pilot-scale example

In a 2019 pilot-scale experiment (Fiedler and colleagues), a gluten-reduced beer was brewed with barley malt in the presence of PEP and then filtered with diatomaceous earth and perlite18. The combination reduced detectable gluten more than either step alone, yet gluten proteins or polypeptides were still observed in the filtered, PEP-treated beers using sandwich ELISA, western blot and mass spectrometry19.

TTB will not approve a label with the “processed to remove gluten” statement unless the label application describes the method used20.

Why a lab result on the finished beer is disputed

FDA says that during fermentation proteins are broken apart into peptides, and that conventional analytical methods may not accurately detect and quantify gluten in fermented foods; beer is one of its examples6. TTB agrees that, as of its 2020 ruling, there was no scientifically valid method to quantify the amount of gluten in fermented or hydrolyzed foods in terms of equivalent amounts of intact gluten protein8.

The test at the center of the dispute

Fiedler and colleagues write that the competitive ELISA is generally considered appropriate for analyzing hydrolysed gluten, but not considered a scientifically valid method for quantifying gluten in fermented or hydrolysed foods, because there is no appropriate reference standard21. Colgrave and colleagues call a competitive ELISA the industry standard and write that it may indicate gluten values under 20 mg/kg, while describing gluten measurement in fermented products as controversial22.

What individual studies reported

  • Colgrave and colleagues, 2017: liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry detected barley hordeins in all beers analyzed, with peptides from all hordein classes found in conventional beers also appearing in many gluten-reduced beers; the authors write that PEP digestion was incomplete in several commercial beers10.
  • Fiedler and colleagues, 2019: gluten composition varied between three replicate pilot-scale productions, which the authors say suggests the gluten profile in beer could differ from batch to batch11.
  • Panda and colleagues, 2015, in a model sorghum beer made with wheat gluten: detectable gluten fell during fermentation and fell further with PEP, only one sandwich ELISA could detect the apparent low levels, and a competitive ELISA with a pepsin-trypsin hydrolysate calibrant was unreliable23.
  • Gluten Free Watchdog, quoted by NCA, says a sandwich ELISA will not adequately detect gluten protein fragments that may be found in fermented products such as beer, and names the competitive R5 ELISA for testing yeast24.

Put side by side, these sources show why one number on a finished beer is contested: Fiedler and colleagues write that the competitive ELISA is not considered a scientifically valid method for fermented foods21, one study found gluten peptides by mass spectrometry although a competitive ELISA may indicate under 20 mg/kg10, 22, and the sources do not agree on sandwich ELISA: one sandwich ELISA detected the low levels in a model beer23, while Gluten Free Watchdog says a sandwich ELISA will not adequately detect gluten protein fragments in fermented products24.

An antibody study on patients’ blood samples

A 2017 study in the Journal of AOAC International, which GIG discusses on its site25, tested serum samples from 31 people with active celiac disease and 29 people without it against barley, rice, traditional beer, gluten-free beer and a gluten-removed beer. It measured antibody binding in the laboratory, and none of the sera bound to proteins in the gluten-free beer26.

Of the seven patients with an IgA response to barley, four also responded to traditional beer and two of those responded to the gluten-removed beer27. The authors write that binding by patients’ serum but not controls’ may indicate residual peptides that are celiac-specific28, and note that no validated testing methods exist to quantify all the hydrolyzed or fermented gluten peptides that might be harmful29.

What the TTB statement on the label says

TTB, the Alcohol and Tobacco Tax and Trade Bureau, sets the labeling rules for malt beverages13. Under TTB Ruling 2020-2, a label or advertisement may state that a beer fermented from a gluten-containing grain was processed, treated or crafted to remove some or all of the gluten, under conditions14. The 2020 ruling did not change TTB’s policy on malt beverages fermented from gluten-containing grains30.

  1. The qualifying statement must appear legibly and conspicuously, immediately adjacent to or as a continuation of the claim. Its wording is “Product fermented from grains containing gluten and [processed or treated or crafted] to remove gluten. The gluten content of this product cannot be verified, and this product may contain gluten.”2
  2. The brewer’s label application must describe in detail the method used to remove gluten; without it TTB will not approve the label20.

What each part tells you

  • “cannot be verified”: TTB agrees with FDA that there is currently no scientifically valid method to quantify the amount of gluten in fermented or hydrolyzed foods as intact gluten protein8.
  • “may contain gluten”: the label states it itself, and TTB treats a gluten-free claim on an alcohol beverage that would not qualify under FDA’s standards as misleading31.
  • No number: labels or advertisements that state a specific level of gluten in a fermented finished product, such as “contains x ppm”, without an appropriate basis or necessary qualification will be considered misleading9.
  • No disease claim: claims that characterize a product’s relationship to a health-related condition such as celiac disease are prohibited unless they comply with TTB’s specific health claim requirements32.

TTB no longer requires the brewer’s gluten test results with the application, except upon request33.

What FDA’s 20 ppm rule does and does not reach in beer

FDA’s definition of gluten-free sets a limit of less than 20 parts per million for the gluten in a food that it covers, and bars gluten-containing grains and ingredients derived from them that were not processed to remove gluten34.

For beer, FDA says that beers not made from gluten-containing grains, or made from them but processed to remove gluten in line with the definition before fermentation, may bear the term gluten-free if they meet the applicable requirements35. Because current tests do not adequately detect and quantify gluten in fermented foods, a maker making that claim must keep records showing the food met the definition, including less than 20 ppm gluten before fermentation or hydrolysis, and must evaluate cross-contact36.

A beer that TTB regulates and that would not qualify under FDA’s standards cannot carry a gluten-free claim: TTB would consider it misleading31. The gluten-removed statement is the wording TTB allows instead2.

You may still see a barley-based gluten-removed beer labeled gluten-free. NCA explains that the Federal Alcohol Administration Act generally requires prior label approval for beverages sold across state lines, but that this may not apply to a product brewed and sold in the same state37.

What the celiac organizations say

Positions as each organization’s own page states them. They are advice for people following a gluten-free diet, not a ruling on any one person’s case.

  • National Celiac Association (NCA): gluten-reduced beers made with barley malt may not be labeled gluten-free, and gluten reduced beers should be avoided by those following a gluten-free diet3. Its page adds that until more is known they should be avoided38, and ties this to testing issues39.
  • Gluten Free Watchdog, as quoted by NCA: drink only hard ciders and beers labeled gluten-free and, at this time, avoid products labeled gluten removed40.
  • Gluten Intolerance Group (GIG): its page separates gluten-free stouts, brewed from grains like sorghum, rice or millet4, from gluten-removed stouts, regular beers that have undergone a process to reduce gluten content5, and says its research shows gluten-removed beers are not a choice it recommends for someone with celiac disease12.

What the label tells you before you buy

  1. Look for a gluten-free claim. TTB allows it on a malt beverage only where the product would be entitled to the claim under FDA’s standards15.
  2. If the label says processed, treated or crafted to remove gluten, look beside it for the statement that the gluten content cannot be verified and the product may contain gluten2.
  3. If the label has an ingredient list, read it for barley, malt and yeast, and compare it with our verdicts for barley, malt extract and brewer’s yeast.
  4. Treat a specific gluten number printed on a fermented product with care: TTB says such a statement without an appropriate basis is misleading9.
  5. Our gluten scanner looks for gluten ingredients in a photo of a label or in pasted text.

Questions people take to their own clinician

This guide reports what regulators, charities and researchers say. It does not tell any one person what to drink. Questions some readers bring to a clinician or registered dietitian:

  • NCA and GIG treat gluten-removed beer differently from beer brewed without gluten grains3, 12. How does that apply to my situation?
  • Studies have reached different results depending on the test method10, 22. What does that mean for someone with my diagnosis?
  • If I choose a beer brewed without gluten grains, what should I check on the label or ask the maker?

Verdicts in this guide

Questions people ask

Is gluten-removed beer gluten-free?

The labeling rules do not treat it as such. TTB considers a gluten-free claim misleading on an alcohol beverage that would not be entitled to it under FDA’s standards31, FDA does not consider fermentation or hydrolysis a process to remove gluten6, 7, and a gluten-removed beer carries the statement “The gluten content of this product cannot be verified, and this product may contain gluten.”2

Can people with celiac disease drink gluten-removed beer?

NCA says gluten reduced beers should be avoided by those following a gluten-free diet3, and GIG says its research shows they are not a choice it recommends for someone with celiac disease12. Your own clinician can speak to your situation.

What does “crafted to remove gluten” mean?

TTB lets a beer fermented from a gluten-containing grain say it was processed, treated or crafted to remove some or all of the gluten, with a qualifying statement beside it14. The brewer must describe the method in its label application20; one reported method uses an enzyme, prolyl endopeptidase1.

Why can’t a lab test settle whether a gluten-removed beer contains gluten?

FDA says conventional analytical methods may not accurately detect and quantify gluten in fermented foods6, and TTB agrees that no scientifically valid method exists to quantify it as intact gluten protein8.

Why did I see a barley-based gluten-removed beer labeled gluten-free?

NCA says federal label approval may not apply to a beer brewed and sold in the same state37.

Can a gluten-removed beer print its ppm on the label?

Not without an appropriate basis. TTB says a statement of a specific level, such as “contains x ppm”, on a fermented finished product without an appropriate basis or necessary qualification will be considered misleading9.

More in Drinks and alcohol

Sources