Hydrolyzed protein, yeast extract and wheat starch on a US food label

Short answer

Look for the source in the name, and ask the maker when it is not there:

  1. Hydrolyzed protein: a US label has to name the food source of the protein, so “hydrolyzed wheat protein” shows wheat and “hydrolyzed vegetable protein” alone is not an acceptable name1, 2.
  2. Wheat starch: it is derived from wheat, and a food labeled gluten-free may use it only if the finished food stays under 20 parts per million of gluten3.
  3. Yeast extract: it may be made from spent brewer’s yeast, and a US label does not have to say whether barley is behind it4, 5.

Published by Gluten Verdict · updated · 21 sources, each linked below

Bouillon tub, soup can, ramen pouch and a red canister on a lit kitchen shelf

Key points

  • A US label has to name the food source of a hydrolyzed protein, and “hydrolyzed vegetable protein” on its own is not an acceptable name1, 2.
  • Yeast extract can come from spent brewer’s yeast, and a US label does not have to say whether barley is behind it4, 5.
  • Wheat starch is allowed in a food labeled gluten-free only when the finished food has less than 20 ppm of gluten, and the label then carries a wheat statement3, 6.
  • Codex describes a similar kind of wheat-derived ingredient processed to remove gluten, with a limit of 20 mg/kg7.

Three names, three different label situations

All three turn up in ingredient lists. What differs is how, or whether, the grain shows up on a US label.

What a US label has to say about each name
IngredientWhat it can come fromDoes a US label name the grain?
Hydrolyzed proteinA plant protein, such as soy or wheat: FDA lists hydrolyzed soy protein and hydrolyzed wheat protein as examples of hydrolyzed foods8.Yes. The name has to include the food source of the protein1.
Yeast extractSpent brewer’s yeast, a beer by-product, or yeast grown on sugar beets4, 9.Not necessarily. Manufacturers are not required to declare barley on the label5.
Wheat starchWheat: FDA’s rule describes it as an ingredient derived from a gluten-containing grain3.Wheat is in the name, and wheat is on the list of major food allergens10.

The sections below take them one at a time, then compare US wheat starch with the Codex standard, and end with what to ask the maker. How a maker proves a gluten-free claim on a fermented or hydrolyzed ingredient is a separate rule; the one-line version is in the questions at the end.

Hydrolyzed protein: the source has to be named

In a hydrolyzed food, a food’s proteins are broken into smaller compounds by reaction with water, often sped up by enzymes11. FDA’s description of its 2020 gluten-free rule names hydrolyzed plant proteins used to improve flavor or texture in processed foods such as soups, sauces and seasonings12. Our verdicts for foods in those aisles include chicken broth.

What the naming rule says

Under 21 CFR 102.22, the name of a protein hydrolysate must be specific and must include the food source of the protein1. The same rule says “hydrolyzed vegetable protein” and “hydrolyzed protein” are not acceptable names because they do not identify the source2. “Hydrolyzed wheat gluten” and “hydrolyzed soy protein” are examples of acceptable ones13.

A hydrolysate used for its effect on flavor also cannot be declared simply as “flavor”, “natural flavor” or “flavoring”14. That rule bars “natural flavor” as the name for a hydrolyzed protein used for its taste14.

Where the wheat declaration comes from

Wheat is on the US list of major food allergens10, and an ingredient that contains protein derived from wheat counts as one15. A maker names wheat in a line that begins with “Contains” next to the ingredient list16, or in parentheses after the ingredient’s name17. The parentheses are not needed when the ingredient’s own name already uses the source, as “hydrolyzed wheat protein” does18.

What it looks like on a package

Pioneer’s Gluten Free Brown Gravy Mix lists “HYDROLYZED VEGETABLE PROTEIN (CORN; SOY)”19. Its Brown Gravy Mix lists “HYDROLYZED VEGETABLE PROTEIN (CORN; SOY; AND/OR WHEAT)”20 and its allergen line begins “CONTAINS ALLERGENS: WHEAT”21. Hormel’s Chili No Beans names the grain inside the ingredient, as “Hydrolyzed Soy, Corn, and Wheat Protein”22.

Our hydrolyzed vegetable protein verdict lists the products we checked and what each maker’s page said.

FDA says hydrolysis is not considered a process to remove gluten, and it gives hydrolyzed wheat protein as one of its examples of a hydrolyzed food8.

Yeast extract: the source is the open question

Yeast extract and autolyzed yeast extract may be made from spent brewer’s yeast, or grown on sugar beets, which are gluten-free4. Spent brewer’s yeast is a by-product of beer brewing and can be contaminated with small amounts of gluten-containing grain and malt9.

A US label cannot settle which one it is. Barley is not on the list of major food allergens10, so the Contains line does not have to mention it. Gluten Free Watchdog (GFWD) says there is no way to know from the label whether yeast extract contains barley protein unless barley is voluntarily declared23. The National Celiac Association (NCA) says the same: manufacturers are not required to declare barley5.

GFWD contrasts this with Canada: under Health Canada regulations, it notes, all gluten sources, including barley, must be declared in packaged food24.

GFWD also reports that FDA told it yeast extract cannot be hidden under “natural flavor” and must be declared25. FDA’s naming rule lists “autolyzed yeast extract” as an acceptable name13.

How the National Celiac Association groups yeast ingredients
Yeast ingredientNCA’s grouping
Baker’s yeast, yeast, autolyzed yeast, nutritional yeast, torula yeastGluten-Free26
Yeast extract, autolyzed yeast extractMay Contain Gluten26
Brewer’s yeastContains Gluten26

What the charities advise

NCA says to check with the manufacturer when yeast extract is listed on a food that is not labeled gluten-free5. On a yeast extract food that is not labeled gluten-free, GFWD recommends that people with celiac disease avoid it unless the manufacturer confirms the source is gluten-free27, and it says it does not know how often yeast extract is spent brewer’s yeast28. The Gluten Intolerance Group (GIG) tells readers to look for yeast extracts and products labeled or third-party certified as gluten-free29.

On a food that does carry the claim, GFWD says that, generally speaking, it does not want people to start worrying about yeast extract27. It has also reported a labeled gluten-free product with the ingredient: a Kirkland Signature turkey breast whose yeast extract, per Costco, may be brewer’s yeast from beer brewing30. GFWD’s page quotes the GFCO manual as saying certified products cannot contain yeast extract grown on culture media that contained proteins from wheat, rye, barley or oats31.

On a package, Zatarain’s Yellow Rice Mix shows what the ingredient list leaves out. McCormick’s page lists “Gluten free”32 and, in the ingredients, yeast extract and hydrolyzed soy protein with no source given for the yeast extract33. Our yeast extract verdict records the products we checked.

Wheat starch: wheat in the name, a statement beside the claim

FDA’s gluten-free rule uses wheat starch as its example of an ingredient derived from a gluten-containing grain and processed to remove gluten. Such an ingredient is allowed in a food labeled gluten-free only if its use does not leave the food at 20 parts per million (ppm) of gluten or more3. GFWD describes wheat starch as an allowed ingredient in US foods labeled gluten-free, considered an ingredient processed to remove gluten34.

Without the claim, the picture changes. Based on testing through GFWD, wheat starch not labeled gluten-free may contain gluten well above 20 ppm35. GIG likewise points out that FDA allows wheat starch in a product labeled gluten-free if the finished product has less than 20 ppm36.

The wheat statement

When a food names wheat in the ingredient list or a Contains statement and also makes a gluten-free claim, the rule treats the food as misbranded unless the word “wheat” is followed by an asterisk that points to this sentence near the ingredient statement: “The wheat has been processed to allow this food to meet the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) requirements for gluten-free foods.”6

On a gluten-free food made with processed wheat, then, the word “wheat” and that sentence can both appear6. King Arthur’s page for its Gluten-Free Bread Flour says it is made with gluten-free wheat starch37.

What GFWD found when it tested

GFWD’s commissioned testing of labeled gluten-free wheat starch and foods made with it found at most 17 ppm of gluten with the competitive R5 ELISA and 6 ppm with the sandwich R5 ELISA38. Its opinion is that wheat starch for gluten-free products should be tested with both methods unless the supplier confirms that no hydrolytic enzymes are used in making the water-washed starch39. GFWD reports that, per GFCO, wheat starch in certified products must be water washed only and test at no more than 5 ppm of gluten with a sandwich ELISA40.

For packages we have checked, see our wheat starch verdict and the Pringles verdict.

Codex wheat starch and the US rule

The Codex standard for foods for people intolerant to gluten (CODEX STAN 118-1979) covers, among its gluten-free foods, those consisting of one or more ingredients from wheat41 that have been specially processed to remove gluten, with a gluten level not above 20 mg/kg in the food as sold7. That resembles the US rule’s category of an ingredient derived from a gluten-containing grain and processed to remove gluten, and the US rule uses the same figure, 20 mg of gluten per kg of food3. The fao.org copy we read is the version amended in 2015; we did not check for later amendments.

The Codex labeling clause says the term “gluten-free” shall be printed in the immediate proximity of the product name for the products described in section 2.1.142. The US rule has a separate requirement, the wheat statement described above, for a label that names wheat and makes the claim6.

Italy as an example

The Italian celiac society AIC says that contamination in the wheat starch then on the market led Italy’s Ministry of Health to exclude the ingredient for years from gluten-free products made for people with celiac disease43. It says a wheat starch it calls “deglutinato” is now available that allows products with a gluten content below 20 ppm44, and that products labeled “senza glutine” made with wheat starch can be found in Italy45. AIC adds that wheat starch that is not “deglutinato”, as commonly used in ordinary food production, remains unsuitable for people with celiac disease46.

A gluten-free claim and a wheat starch line can appear on the same package, in the US6 and in Italy45 alike. Read the ingredient list for “wheat starch” even when the front of a domestic or imported package carries a claim.

At the shelf: what to check and what to ask

  1. Read the whole ingredient list, not only the Contains line. Barley, which can sit behind yeast extract47, is not on the US allergen list10.
  2. If the label says only “hydrolyzed vegetable protein” or “hydrolyzed protein”, no source is named; FDA’s rule says those names are not acceptable2. Look for the source in parentheses17 or in the Contains line16.
  3. If wheat starch is listed, look for a gluten-free claim and the asterisked sentence that goes with it6.
  4. If yeast extract is listed on a food with no gluten-free claim, NCA says to check with the manufacturer5. GFWD says it is important to ask whether spent yeast is the source48.

For wheat starch in a gluten-free food, GFWD suggests asking the maker either of two questions: whether the wheat starch is tested with both a sandwich and a competitive ELISA, or whether the supplier has confirmed that no hydrolytic enzymes are used in making the water-washed starch49.

See also our verdicts for soy sauce and miso. For soy sauce, FDA says that in general soy sauce made from soybeans and wheat, or another gluten-containing grain, may not bear a gluten-free claim50. Recipes change, so the package in your hand has the final word.

Verdicts in this guide

Questions people ask

Is hydrolyzed vegetable protein gluten-free?

The name alone does not say. A US label has to name the food source of the protein1. FDA lists hydrolyzed soy protein and hydrolyzed wheat protein as examples of hydrolyzed foods and says hydrolysis is not considered a process to remove gluten8.

Can a hydrolyzed product made from wheat carry a gluten-free claim?

FDA says a hydrolyzed or fermented food product made from gluten-containing grains may not bear a gluten-free claim unless the grains were processed to remove gluten and the use of the ingredient resulted in less than 20 ppm gluten in the food before hydrolysis or fermentation51.

Is autolyzed yeast extract different from yeast extract?

NCA says both may contain gluten from barley47. Its table lists plain autolyzed yeast under gluten-free26.

Why would a gluten-free food say “wheat”?

A food that names wheat and makes the claim must carry a sentence saying the wheat has been processed to meet FDA’s gluten-free requirements6.

More in Hidden gluten in ingredients, sauces and processed foods

Sources