The Contains line names wheat, not barley or rye: what US allergen labels cover

Short answer

The Contains line comes from the US allergen law, and that law’s list of major allergens names wheat but not barley or rye1, 2. A food can therefore hold barley or rye gluten, malt for example, with no Contains entry for it3, 43, so read the ingredient list too and look for a gluten-free claim, the statement that carries FDA’s gluten rule4.

Published by Gluten Verdict · updated · 13 sources, each linked below

Snack box on its side with folded lime-green reading glasses on a kitchen counter

Key points

  • When a pack prints a Contains line, it names the major allergens in the food14. Of the three gluten grains, wheat is the only one on the US list1, 5.
  • FDA’s allergen guidance counts spelt, einkorn, emmer, Khorasan and triticale as wheat6.
  • Barley and rye are not allergens under the law, so malt and other barley names need not say barley3.
  • Cross-contact is not declared in the Contains line7; a may-contain line is voluntary and separate41.
  • The allergen rules cover FDA-regulated packaged food, except most meat and poultry8, and TTB says its current regulations do not require major food allergens to be disclosed on alcohol labels9.

What the Contains line is, and where it sits

The Contains line exists because of the Food Allergen Labeling and Consumer Protection Act of 2004, known as FALCPA10. It gives a maker two ways to name a major allergen. One is a line starting with the word “Contains”, printed right after or next to the ingredient list10. The other is to follow the ingredient’s name in the list with the allergen’s food source in parentheses11.

FDA’s sesame page shows both in one example label: “spices (sesame, wheat)” in the ingredient list and “CONTAINS: Wheat, Sesame” under it12. A maker may use either way, and each pack has to use one13.

When a pack does print a Contains line, FDA’s guidance says it is to name every major allergen that is in the food or in an ingredient of the food14. That matters in one direction: wheat can appear only in the Contains line. FDA gives the example of wheat flour used on a processing belt for rice crackers; if the ingredient list does not say wheat, the Contains line must15. So for wheat, read both.

GIG describes the wheat statements as required “to alert wheat-allergic consumers”16.

The nine major allergens, and where the gluten grains sit

FDA lists the major food allergens as milk, egg, fish, Crustacean shellfish, tree nuts, wheat, peanuts, soybeans and sesame1. Sesame is the newest: it has had to be labeled on packaged foods since January 1, 202317. Wheat has been on the list since the 2004 Act, which said eight foods account for 90 percent of food allergies18, 19.

Where each grain stands on the US allergen list
GrainOn the major-allergen list?What that means on the label
WheatYes1Named as “wheat” in the Contains line or in parentheses in the ingredient list10, 11.
BarleyNo2Barley is not on the list1, and FDA’s guidance says the Contains statement is reserved for major food allergens43. Malt made from barley need not say barley3. See our barley verdict.
RyeNo2Rye is not on the list1, and the Contains statement is reserved for major food allergens43. GIG says barley and rye are not given the same treatment on ingredient labels20.
Triticale (a wheat and rye cross)Counted as wheat for this purpose6The gluten-free rule describes it as a cross between wheat and rye21.
OatsNo1FDA’s Q&A on the gluten-free rule says oats labeled gluten-free must contain less than 20 ppm gluten, as with any other non-gluten-containing grain22. See oatmeal.

The same 2004 Act is where gluten gets its own track. Section 206 told the Secretary of Health and Human Services to define, and permit the use of, the term “gluten-free” on food labels23. That is why the Contains line and the gluten-free claim answer different questions, and why our guide to reading a US food label for gluten starts with the claim.

What counts as “wheat” on the line

For the allergen rules, FDA’s guidance says “wheat” means any species in the genus Triticum24. Its list of examples includes durum, spelt, semolina, einkorn, emmer, khorasan and triticale6. A pack that contains any of them names wheat in one of the two ways above6, 13. Our guide to wheat grains with other names goes through them.

The gluten-free rule draws a wider circle. In 21 CFR 101.91, a “gluten-containing grain” is wheat, rye or barley, or a crossbred hybrid of them5, 21. So the allergen law names one of those three grains, and the gluten-free rule names all three1, 5. Our guide to the FDA gluten-free rule covers what the 20 ppm limit measures.

Barley and rye: what the line leaves to the ingredient list

The Gluten Intolerance Group (GIG) explains the gap this way: in the US gluten is not considered a top allergen (wheat is, but barley and rye are not), so it is easy for gluten to “hide” behind other names in ingredient lists2. GIG’s label-reading article adds that anything derived from barley or rye in an ingredient list, such as malt from barley, does not need to say where it came from3.

That is why the ingredient list has to be read word by word. These are the names that stand in for barley or rye, with the sources that name them:

Ingredient-list names that can carry barley gluten without a Contains entry
Name on the labelWhat the sources say
Malt, malt extract, malt syrup, malt flavoring, malted barley flourFDA says malt extract and malt syrup are derived from barley that has not been processed to remove gluten25. The Celiac Disease Foundation lists malt in these forms among gluten sources26. See malt extract and our guide to malt on labels.
Malt vinegarListed by the Celiac Disease Foundation as one of the forms of malt26.
Brewer’s yeastOn the Celiac Disease Foundation’s list of gluten-containing grains and their derivatives27.
Yeast extractGIG says some yeast extract is made from spent brewer’s yeast and could contain residual barley gluten, and that in the US the source may not be clear because barley is not a major allergen28.
Natural flavorGIG says wheat must be declared when present in a natural flavor, but US labels may not always identify barley or rye the same way29.
Beer, ale, lagerGIG lists them among barley-derived sources unless specifically brewed gluten-free30.

An example from our records: Rice Krispies

Our Rice Krispies verdict shows the gap on a real product. WK Kellogg’s SmartLabel page for the 9 oz cereal lists rice, sugar, salt and malt flavor31, and its allergen section reads “Does not contain Declaration Obligatory Allergens”32. The maker’s own FAQ says the cereal does not list wheat as an allergen but is not labeled gluten free because it contains malt, and that the malt comes from barley and may contain gluten33. No allergen is declared on the SmartLabel page, yet the maker says the malt in its ingredient list comes from barley32, 33.

Canada draws the line differently. GIG says Canadian labels are especially helpful for finding barley and rye, which do not get the same mandatory source declaration in the United States34. Our guide to gluten source declaration by country compares the rules.

What the Contains line does not cover

  • Cross-contact. FDA’s guidance says allergens present because of cross-contact are not to be declared in the ingredients list or the Contains statement7. Statements about shared equipment, such as “may contain wheat”, are voluntary in the US41; our guide to may-contain wheat labels explains them.
  • Foods outside FDA’s rule. The allergen requirements apply to packaged foods subject to FDA regulation, except most meat, poultry, catfish and certain processed egg products8. GIG says packaged meats are USDA-regulated and most, but not all, also comply with FALCPA35.
  • Alcohol. TTB’s FAQ says current regulations under the Federal Alcohol Administration Act do not require major food allergens to be disclosed on alcohol labels9. Under TTB’s interim rule a maker may declare them but need not42; if it declares any one, it must list all that were used in production36.
  • Oats. They are not an allergen on the list1, and GIG says the cross-contact risk with gluten is high for oats, so it advises looking for a certification on oat products37.

Wheat on a gluten-free pack

A pack can name wheat and still carry a gluten-free claim, but only with a required statement. Under 21 CFR 101.91(b)(3), when “wheat” appears in the ingredient list or in a Contains wheat line and the pack also says gluten-free, the word “wheat” has to be followed by an asterisk that points to this wording near the ingredient statement: “The wheat has been processed to allow this food to meet the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) requirements for gluten-free foods.” Without it the food is deemed misbranded38.

So “wheat” in a Contains line on a pack that also says gluten-free is not a contradiction: the required statement says the wheat has been processed so the food meets FDA’s gluten-free requirements38. The asterisk statement applies only to a pack that also makes the gluten-free claim38, and in FDA’s gluten-free rule wheat is one of the gluten-containing grains21. Our guide to hidden sources of gluten and guide to wheat, barley and rye names list what else to look for.

A reading routine for the Contains line

  1. Look for a gluten-free claim first. On an FDA-regulated food it has to meet the rule in 21 CFR 101.914.
  2. Read the Contains line. FDA’s guidance counts spelt, einkorn, emmer, Khorasan and triticale as wheat6. No “wheat” there is not a statement about barley or rye2.
  3. Read the whole ingredient list, not just the Contains line39, and stop at malt, malt extract, malt flavoring, brewer’s yeast, yeast extract, rye and barley.
  4. Treat a may-contain line as a separate, voluntary note41; see may-contain wheat labels.
  5. If the pack has no claim and the list is unclear, check our verdict A to Z for the product, or paste the label into our gluten scanner. The maker has the final word on its own recipe.

Verdicts in this guide

Questions people ask

If a food has no “Contains wheat” line, is it gluten-free?

Not on that evidence alone. The line names wheat but not barley or rye2, so a food with malt can have no wheat entry. A gluten-free claim is what carries FDA’s rule4.

Does “Contains wheat” mean the food has gluten?

Wheat is a gluten-containing grain in FDA’s gluten-free rule21. The exception is a pack that also makes a gluten-free claim and carries the required asterisk statement about processed wheat38.

Why does the line not list barley when malt comes from barley?

Barley is not a major allergen, so GIG says malt from barley does not need to name its source3. FDA says malt extract and malt syrup are derived from barley25.

Is “wheat-free” the same as gluten-free?

No. The Celiac Disease Foundation says a wheat-free product may still contain spelt, rye or barley-based ingredients40.

Do beer and wine labels have a Contains line?

On labels under TTB’s rules, only if the maker chooses to add one. TTB says its regulations do not require allergen disclosure on alcohol labels9, and its interim rule lets makers declare allergens but does not require it42.

More in Label reading and gluten-free claims

Sources