Gluten-free grocery pickup and delivery: setting substitutions and checking swaps

Short answer

Choose a substitution setting for each item you picked for its label, and read the package of every swap as a new product, because Instacart’s own help page says the nutritional information it shows is not a substitute for checking product labels, and that packaging in store may differ from what it shows1, 2. These steps come from three retailers’ own help pages, read on 2026-11-17:

  1. Before you order, set the items you chose for a label to a refund on Instacart3, “Don’t substitute” at Target4 or “Don’t Substitute” at Whole Foods Market on Amazon5.
  2. While the order is shopped, approve or decline each swap the retailer offers6, 7, 8.
  3. At the door, read the pack: the gluten-free claim9, then the Contains line and the full ingredient list10.
  4. If a swap fails, decline it before pickup where the retailer lets you, as Target does7, 11, or report it: Instacart takes reports within three days of pickup or delivery12.

Published by Gluten Verdict · updated · 16 sources, each linked below

An open car trunk with plastic grocery bags and a person lifting out a carton

Key points

  • On Instacart, if you pick nothing, “Replace with best match” is selected for you, and shoppers also use replacements you approved on past orders13.
  • Instacart’s refund option does not end swap suggestions: the shopper may still suggest a replacement for you to approve or decline3.
  • A “gluten-free” claim on a pack means less than 20 parts per million of gluten on foods FDA regulates9, but the claim is voluntary and may be missing from a food that is gluten-free14.
  • Instacart says the packaging in store may contain more or different information than its listing shows1.
  • We did not read Walmart’s or Kroger’s help pages for this guide, so it makes no claim about their settings.

Where the swap decision is made

A swap is decided twice: in the setting you choose before the order is shopped, and by a person in the store when an item is missing. The table is each retailer’s own description of both, as its help page reads today.

Substitution choices on three retailers’ help pages (read 2026-11-17)
RetailerWhat you can chooseIf you choose nothingWho picks the swap
InstacartPer item: replace with best match, replace with a specific item (up to 3 options), or refund the item24, 15Replace with best match is selected for you13With best match, the shopper picks the best possible replacement and also uses replacements you approved on past orders13; with a specific item, you choose up to 3 options15
Target: Order Pickup and Drive UpIn the app, one preferred substitute per item16; at checkout, “Don’t substitute”17, best available18 or your pick19The page names no default among these20Target; with best available, you approve or reject each swap before pickup7
Target: Same Day DeliveryPer item, one preferred substitute56; or for the whole order, text me21, choose for me57, or don’t substitute58Text me: the shopper and you decide on substitutes together over text, and this is the default21The shopper, with you by text unless you chose otherwise21
Whole Foods Market on Amazon“Don’t Substitute” at checkout, per item5Team members suggest a similar product, and you can accept or decline it22, 8Whole Foods team members suggest the swap59; you accept or decline23

We did not read Walmart’s or Kroger’s help pages, so this guide says nothing about their settings. Open the substitution setting in their own apps before you order.

Setting substitutions before you order

Set the choice on every item you picked because of its label: a gluten-free claim, a certifier mark, or one specific variety. The choice is per item on Instacart24, Target4 and Whole Foods Market on Amazon5, so a cart can mix locked items with items you are happy to leave to the shopper.

Instacart

  1. In the app, open the item in your cart, tap Add Instructions, tap Choose replacement, then pick a specific item, best match, or refund24.
  2. Pick “Refund this item” for an item you prefer not to have replaced: you get a refund instead3.
  3. Remember the exception: the shopper may still suggest a replacement, and you then approve or decline it3.
  4. Your replacement instructions carry over to future orders, so set them once, then check them before you reorder25.

Target

  • The page says substitutions are available in the Target app26, for eligible items in Order Pickup, Drive Up and Same Day Delivery orders27.
  • For Order Pickup and Drive Up, to opt out in checkout: select Edit next to Substitution Preference, then select “Don’t substitute” for each item in the list4.
  • For Same Day Delivery, check the cart first: Target says that if you added a substitute to an item in the past, it remembers it28.

Whole Foods Market on Amazon

  • Select “Don’t Substitute” during checkout, so team members know to skip the replacement5.

Some grocery categories come in versions with a gluten-free claim and versions without one, so one swap can change the answer. Our verdicts show it for pasta, bread, crackers, tortillas, cereal, granola bars, oatmeal and soy sauce. Those are the first items to lock.

What to write in the item note

On Instacart you can add an item instruction from the cart, on the checkout page, or after you order, as long as the shopper has not started on it29. Instruction notes carry over to future orders, so review them when you order the same item again30.

Our advice is to use the replacement setting for the decision and the note for the detail a person needs. A note a shopper can follow names the exact product and the one thing to check:

  • Only this exact product, with “gluten-free” on the front of the pack.
  • If it is out, do not replace it.
  • If you must suggest something, message me first with the brand and the full product name.

Instacart’s own page says a shopper may still suggest a replacement even when you chose a refund3, so neither a note nor a setting replaces the check at the door below.

While the order is being shopped

  • Instacart: you can edit items, notes and replacements until your shopper begins shopping31. After that, chat with the shopper to request changes or ask about replacements32. To approve a change, select Approve; to prefer another option, select Other options, and if it is not listed, chat with the shopper6.
  • Target Order Pickup and Drive Up with best available: you approve or reject the substitutions before you pick your order up7.
  • Target Same Day Delivery: you can update substitution choices until your order is being shopped33.
  • Whole Foods Market on Amazon: with text messaging set up, you get a text naming the out-of-stock item and a suggested replacement, and you accept or decline it in the Amazon in-app chat23.

When you are asked about a swap, ask for the brand and the full product name, then read that product’s own page before you accept. Accepting is the same as buying a new product.

The check at the door: read the pack, not the order screen

Instacart’s own page says the nutritional information it shows “isn’t a substitute for checking product labels”2, and that the packaging in store may contain more or different information than its listing1. In April 2023 FDA issued a request for information to learn more about the content, format and accuracy of the food labeling information that online grocery platforms provide34. FDA’s own advice is that consumers with celiac disease should read and scrutinize labels to avoid gluten ingredients35. So the package in your hand is the label that counts. Check it in this order:

  1. Is it the product you chose? Compare the brand, the full name and the size with your order. A swap can be another variety from the same maker.
  2. Look for a gluten-free claim on the pack. On foods FDA regulates, the claim means less than 20 parts per million of gluten9. The claim is voluntary and can be missing from a food that is gluten-free14, so a pack without one is a pack you read in full.
  3. Read the Contains line if the pack has one, then the whole ingredient list. Under US law (FALCPA), where a Contains line is used, it follows the ingredient list or sits next to it36. The Gluten Intolerance Group notes that wheat is a top allergen in the US but barley and rye are not, so gluten can hide behind other names in an ingredient list37. The Gluten Intolerance Group says to read the full list, not just the Contains statement10.
  4. If there is no gluten-free claim, the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics says to look in the ingredient list for wheat, rye, barley, oats and malt38.
  5. If you rely on a certifier’s mark, confirm it in the certifier’s own directory. FDA does not endorse or accredit any one certification program39. For GFCO, a product counts as certified if it appears on the Product Finder and carries the mark40; a listed product whose pack lacks the mark is not certified41, and GFCO certifies physical products that display its mark42.
  6. Still unsure? Do not eat it. Decline or report it, or ask the maker using what to ask a food maker.

Our gluten scanner can read pasted ingredient text or a photo of the label, and our verdict pages show what each maker’s own pages said, with the date we read them: every verdict, A to Z. The Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics adds a habit that suits swaps and reorders alike: read the label each time you buy a product, even one you have had before, because the manufacturer may change an ingredient43.

Refusing, returning and getting refunded

Instacart

  • You can report an issue in the app or on the website within three days of pickup or delivery, and Instacart can issue a credit or refund for eligible issues12. Report each issue separately44.
  • The page lists poor replacements among the issues you can report45.
  • Instacart may issue a refund or credit up to the amount you paid for an item46. If you report within 24 hours of receiving the order, you may receive a same-day refund47. Not all issues automatically qualify48.
  • Returns are subject to the store’s own return policies, and certain retailers may not accept Instacart customer returns49. Grocery items such as fresh produce, deli items and beverages cannot be returned in-store; for those you contact Instacart Customer Experience directly50.
  • A swapped item you accepted is charged or refunded at the price difference51.

Target and Whole Foods Market

  • Target Order Pickup and Drive Up: you are charged only for the substitutes you accept and refunded for the others11. A substitute you receive is charged at its own price, so your final total can change52.
  • Whole Foods Market on Amazon: you can accept or decline a replacement23. We did not read Target’s return rules for a substitute taken home or Whole Foods’ refund pages for this guide; check the order screen of each.

If you think a labeled food was wrong, or someone got ill

FDA advises that anyone who thinks they or a family member has an illness associated with having eaten a particular food contact their healthcare provider immediately and keep any food packages, because the packages may contain important information. Labeling concerns may also be reported to FDA53. FDA’s page lists what a report should include, among them where the product was bought, codes on the label and photos of the product, label and lot code54. Keep the swapped pack, the order receipt and a photo of the label.

Repeat orders and saved preferences

  • Instacart’s best-match shopper also uses replacements you approved on past orders13, and your replacement instructions carry over25. Approve a swap only if you would accept it again.
  • Target says it will remember a preferred substitute if you reorder the original item55.
  • Whatever the app remembers, the label can change: read the label each time you buy43.

For a longer look at the listing before you order, see how to check a grocery listing for gluten and our shopping tips.

A short test for accepting a swap

Accept a swap only when all three are true; otherwise decline it, or take it only after you have read it like a new product:

  1. It is the same maker and the same variety, or you have found the exact replacement’s page and read it.
  2. The pack carries a gluten-free claim, or you have read the full ingredient list and found none of the words the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics lists to look for: wheat, rye, barley, oats and malt38.
  3. If you rely on a certifier’s mark, it is on the pack and in the certifier’s directory40.

Verdicts in this guide

Questions people ask

Can I stop substitutions altogether?

At Target you can opt out by selecting “Don’t substitute” for each item at checkout4, and at Whole Foods Market on Amazon you select “Don’t Substitute”5. On Instacart you choose a refund for the item, but the shopper may still suggest a replacement for you to approve or decline3.

Do I have to accept a replacement?

It depends on the setting. On Instacart you approve or decline a suggested replacement3; at Target Order Pickup and Drive Up with best available, you approve or reject each substitution before pickup7; at Whole Foods Market on Amazon you accept or decline8. Target Same Day Delivery’s “Choose for me” lets the shopper use their best judgement to pick a substitute57, so choose “Don’t substitute” there if you want no swap58.

Will a replacement cost the same as what I ordered?

Not always. Instacart refunds or charges you the price difference51, and Target charges the price of the substitute you receive52.

How long do I have to report a wrong item on Instacart?

Three days after pickup or delivery44.

More in Grocery shopping and meal planning

Sources