A starter gluten-free pantry: 30 shelf items and the label check for each

Short answer

We sorted the 30 shelf items below by the check each needs: 9 need only a quick look at the ingredient list, 11 need the full label read, and 10 are best bought labeled or certified gluten-free. GIG says label reading is essential, and includes certified gluten-free logos, “gluten-free” labeled foods and ingredient lists1. In this order:

  1. Start with the nine plain staples (rice, quinoa, dried and canned beans, nuts, cooking oil, vinegar, honey and maple syrup) and check only that nothing was added. NIDDK lists rice among naturally gluten-free foods without additives or some seasonings, and GIG calls beans naturally gluten-free2, 3.
  2. Add the ten that are best bought as a labeled or certified version: pasta, oats, cornstarch, lentils, soy sauce, pure spices, flour blend, cereal, bars and crackers4, 5, 6.
  3. Read the ingredient list on the other eleven, because some brands and recipes add gluten, such as wheat flour in some specialty mustards or hydrolyzed wheat protein in some broths7, 8.
  4. In a shared home, sort out the toaster, colander and spreads before the shelf9, 10, 11.

Published by Gluten Verdict · updated · 21 sources, each linked below

Pantry shelf of jars, rice bags and tins with one hand straightening a tin

Key points

  • A gluten-free label on a food FDA regulates means less than 20 ppm; GFCO certification means 10 ppm or less12, 13.
  • For lentils, oats and cornstarch, GIG and an NCA dietitian point to labeled or certified versions4, 14, 6.
  • FDA says malt vinegar cannot be used in a food bearing a gluten-free claim, and soy sauce made from soybeans and wheat generally may not bear one15, 5.
  • Skip bulk bins: GIG says any item in one is considered risky16.
  • In a shared kitchen, GIG advises squeezable condiments, gluten-free foods stored above gluten-containing ones, and a designated toaster17, 18, 9.

How the 30 items are tagged

Each item carries one of three tags. The tags are our reading of what the sources below say about the item. They are not a verdict on any brand: where we have checked products, the item links to our verdict.

  • Quick look. The plain product is gluten-free by nature, so you check only that nothing was added. NIDDK says many foods, such as rice, without additives or some seasonings, are naturally gluten-free2.
  • Read the label. It depends on the brand or the recipe, so read the ingredient list and any gluten-free claim each time you buy.
  • Labeled version. Buy one labeled gluten-free or certified, either because the usual version contains gluten or because the Gluten Intolerance Group (GIG) singles the item out for cross-contact.

“Labeled” and “certified” are not the same promise. On a food FDA regulates, a gluten-free label means less than 20 parts per million (ppm) of gluten12. GIG notes that a label claim is not third-party verified, and that GFCO’s certification standard is 10 ppm of gluten or less13. GFCO certifies products that carry its mark, not brands or factories19.

A missing claim on a naturally gluten-free food is not a warning. FDA says the claim is not required, so it may not appear even if the food is gluten-free20.

Grains and starches

Six grain and starch items
ItemTagWhat to check
RiceQuick lookNIDDK names rice among naturally gluten-free foods2. Seasoned rice can carry soy sauce solids, wheat flour or wheat starch, and a pilaf can be made with orzo21, 22. Our verdict: rice.
QuinoaQuick lookGIG lists quinoa among its gluten-free grains23. Buy it in a package rather than from a bulk bin (see the last section). Our verdict: quinoa.
Corn tortillasRead the labelAn NCA dietitian advises making sure corn-based flours such as masa are labeled gluten free, because they could have had cross-contact with gluten-containing grains in processing6. That answer does not name tortillas, so read the tortilla package itself. Our verdict shows what the brands we read list: corn tortillas.
PastaLabeled versionFDA lists pastas among foods that typically contain gluten24. GIG’s list names gluten-free pastas made from rice, corn, quinoa, amaranth, millet or legumes25. Our verdict: pasta.
OatsLabeled versionOats labeled gluten-free must contain less than 20 ppm of gluten, and FDA does not require oats to be certified to carry the claim26. GIG’s pantry list says to choose oats that are certified gluten-free, and adds that anyone with celiac disease should consult a physician or dietitian before including oats14. In its certification review, GFCO gives oats its highest ingredient risk level27. Our verdict: oatmeal.
CornstarchLabeled versionThe same NCA dietitian names cornstarch among the corn-based products to buy labeled gluten free6. Our verdict: cornstarch.

Beans, lentils and nuts

Four bean, lentil and nut items
ItemTagWhat to check
Dried beans and chickpeasQuick lookGIG calls beans naturally gluten-free3. For dry beans it says washing and visually sorting for a stray grain works very well28. Our verdict: chickpeas.
Canned beansQuick lookThe same naturally gluten-free beans3. NIDDK’s caveat is additives or seasonings2, so read the list on any flavored or sauced can.
LentilsLabeled versionGIG says lentils carry a higher cross-contact risk than other legumes or beans, so they should be labeled gluten-free or GFCO certified4. Our verdict: lentils.
NutsQuick lookGIG says plain, packaged nuts do not typically contain gluten, and to avoid nuts from bulk bins29.

Oils, vinegar and sweeteners

Four oil, vinegar and sweetener items
ItemTagWhat to check
Cooking oilQuick lookIn its certification review, GFCO treats fats and oils that do not have any protein as low-risk ingredients that do not require testing30. Read a cooking spray: GIG says certain brands contain wheat flour, but most do not31. Our verdict: olive oil.
Vinegar (white or apple cider)Quick lookGIG says most vinegars are gluten-free and the one to avoid is malt vinegar32; FDA says malt vinegar cannot be used in a food bearing a gluten-free claim15. On a product that is not labeled or certified, the bare word “vinegar” could mean malt vinegar33. Our verdicts: vinegar and apple cider vinegar.
HoneyQuick lookGIG says honey is naturally gluten-free34, and its farmers market list says to check local honey for added flavors and for processing in a shared facility35. Our verdict: honey.
Maple syrupQuick lookGIG says pure maple syrup is naturally gluten-free36. Our verdict: maple syrup.

Sauces, seasonings and broth

Eight sauce, seasoning and broth items
ItemTagWhat to check
Soy sauceLabeled versionFDA says soy sauce is ordinarily made by fermenting soybeans and wheat, and that soy sauce made with wheat generally may not bear a gluten-free claim5. GIG says tamari is often but not always gluten-free37. Our verdict: soy sauce.
BrothRead the labelGIG says some powdered or packaged broths contain gluten, such as yeast extract derived from barley, or hydrolyzed wheat protein8. Our verdict: chicken broth.
Pure spicesLabeled versionGIG says spices are used in small amounts, which reduces but does not eliminate the risk of exposure38, and advises choosing spices labeled gluten-free or GFCO certified39. Our verdict: spices.
Spice blendsRead the labelGIG’s list reads “pure spices are gluten-free, but be cautious of mixed spice packages”40, and it says certain brands of taco seasoning contain wheat41.
MustardRead the labelGIG says wheat flour could be added as a thickener in some specialty mustards, English mustard among them7. Our verdict: mustard.
Hot sauceRead the labelGIG’s list names hot sauce among its condiments25. Brands differ: hot sauce.
KetchupRead the labelGIG says some brands of specialty ketchup may use additional ingredients such as malt vinegar or miso, which may not be gluten-free42.
Salad dressingRead the labelGIG says salad dressings may contain malt vinegar, soy sauce or flour43; its list reads “gluten-free salad dressing (or make your own)”25.

Baking basics

Three baking items
ItemTagWhat to check
Gluten-free flour blendLabeled versionGIG says to choose certified or gluten-free labeled products for lentils and for any milled products made from grains, seeds or legumes44. Our verdict on one brand’s blends: King Arthur gluten-free flour.
Baking powderRead the labelGIG’s baking list names baking powder, baking soda and vanilla extract25. Brands differ: baking powder.
Vanilla extractRead the labelRead the list on the bottle you buy. Our verdict: vanilla extract.

Breakfast and snacks

Five breakfast and snack items
ItemTagWhat to check
CerealLabeled versionGIG says some popular corn flake and crisp rice cereals are made with malt from barley45.
Granola and energy barsLabeled versionGIG says many are made with oats and often are not labeled or certified gluten-free46.
CrackersLabeled versionGIG’s list names gluten-free crackers25. FDA lists breads, cakes, cereals, pastas and many other grain-based foods as typically containing gluten24.
Potato and corn chipsRead the labelFor processed and flavored chips, GIG says some brands use wheat starch or whole wheat in their reconstituted chips, as opposed to sliced potatoes or corn only47.
Peanut butter and tahiniRead the labelGIG’s list names nut butters25. What jars listed: peanut butter and tahini.

In a mixed household: spreads, toaster, colander and shelves

GIG’s pantry bulletin asks the layout question up front: will the whole kitchen be gluten-free, or a shared space? In a shared kitchen it suggests sealed containers, with gluten-free foods stored above those that contain gluten48.

Jars and spreads

  • GIG’s list says to buy condiments in squeezable containers in a shared kitchen, to avoid cross-contact by double dipping17.
  • GIG calls double-dipping, the use of the same serving utensil in both types of food, one of the most common ways crumbs get into gluten-free food49. If a jar is shared, it says housemates need to understand why50.
  • Coeliac UK, a UK charity, suggests separate condiments, or at least clean cutlery for shared butters, jams and spreads11.

Toaster, colander and boards

  • Toaster: GIG puts toasters, air fryers and blenders at the top of its list of appliances to designate gluten-free only9, and offers a toaster bag as a temporary solution when a second appliance is not an option yet51. Coeliac UK says to use toaster bags or consider a separate toaster52.
  • Colander: GIG says colanders, sifters and waffle irons are harder to clean thoroughly and should not be shared if possible; if they are, clean them thoroughly between every use10. It notes that starchy pastas can leave residue in mesh-like strainers53.
  • Boards and wooden tools: Coeliac UK says you may want separate bread boards54. GIG says wood fibers could harbor gluten particles55.

The two charities treat sponges differently. Coeliac UK says you do not need separate cloths or sponges56; GIG says shared sponges and dish rags should be replaced or laundered frequently57.

Shelves and labels

In the same fridge or cupboard, GIG says to put gluten-free packages above gluten-containing ones and keep them securely packaged18. It also suggests labeling food, utensils and cookware when in doubt58, and assigning one color to everything strictly gluten-free, such as cutting boards, mixing bowls and storage containers59.

When only some members of a household are gluten-free, GIG recommends a separate set of the hard-to-clean items strictly for gluten-free food prep60. The kitchen setup guide goes through what to replace, wash or share, and the pantry clean-out guide covers the old stock.

Buying and restocking

Skip the bulk bins. GIG says any item in a bulk bin is considered risky and should be avoided16, because gluten-containing ingredients could linger on scoops or surrounding bins61.

Recipes and sourcing change. GIG’s list ends with a reminder to always confirm the gluten-free status of foods purchased every time you shop62, so a favorite jar gets its label read again when the package looks different.

One cost point we can source: GIG’s 2021 bean article, citing the Northarvest Bean Growers Association, says dry beans cost about half the price per serving of store-brand canned beans63. We give no basket total, because no source we have read prices a gluten-free first stock-up. Gluten-free on a budget covers what costs extra, and the gluten-free grocery list goes aisle by aisle.

Verdicts in this guide

Questions people ask

Does every item in a gluten-free pantry need a gluten-free label?

No. FDA says the claim is not required, so a naturally gluten-free food may not carry it20. The tags above separate plain staples from items where a labeled version is worth buying.

What is the difference between a gluten-free label and a GFCO mark?

A label means less than 20 ppm of gluten on a food FDA regulates12. GIG says a label is not third-party verified, while GFCO’s certification standard is 10 ppm or less13, and GFCO certifies products, not brands or factories19.

More in Grocery shopping and meal planning

Sources