When a gluten-free label looks wrong: what to keep, who to tell, where to look

Short answer

In the US, keep the package and report the product to the agency that regulates it: FDA evaluates each report, and a report is not a finding1, 2. In four steps:

  1. Keep the package, and photograph the claim, the ingredient list and the lot code, expiration date and UPC code3, 4; for meat, poultry and egg products USDA also asks for any uneaten portion25.
  2. Tell the maker or the store if you want an answer from them; FDA’s report page does not ask you to do that first, and USDA says you can complain to the store or the maker if you choose not to make a formal complaint to USDA5, 6.
  3. Report to FDA for most packaged foods and supplements7, to USDA for meat, poultry and egg products8, and to state or local agencies for a restaurant or store9.
  4. Check the recall lists: FDA’s recalls list and Enforcement Report, and USDA’s recalls page10, 11, 12.

Published by Gluten Verdict · updated · 15 sources, each linked below

Hand zipping an opened food package into a bag on a kitchen counter beside a phone

Key points

  • A gluten-free claim and an ingredient list that does not fit together is a mismatch FDA names: it says malt extract and malt vinegar cannot be used in a food that bears the claim13, 14.
  • FDA’s rule applies to packaged foods, including dietary supplements; reports about restaurant food go to state and local agencies15, 9.
  • FDA’s coordinator phone numbers were retired on October 1, 2024; older pages that still send you to one are out of date16, 17.
  • A product missing from a recall list is not cleared: FDA says not all recalls are posted on its recalls list10.
  • A report does not decide the question: FDA says it evaluates each report to decide what follow-up is needed2.

What counts as a label problem

Under FDA’s definition, a gluten-free food either is inherently gluten free or contains none of these: a gluten grain as an ingredient; an ingredient made from one that was not processed to remove gluten; or an ingredient made from one that was processed to remove gluten, if its use leaves 20 parts per million (ppm) or more gluten in the food. Any unavoidable gluten must be under 20 ppm18. A food labeled gluten-free cannot be made on purpose with any amount of a gluten grain, or of an ingredient from one that was not processed to remove gluten19. The rule covers packaged foods, including dietary supplements15.

That makes some combinations a clear mismatch and others not. This table separates them.

What you see on the label, and what FDA says about it
What you seeWhat FDA says
Malt extract, malt syrup or another similar malt-derived ingredient in a food that says gluten-freeThese cannot be used in a food that bears a gluten-free claim13.
Malt vinegar in a food that says gluten-freeIt cannot be used in a food that bears the claim14.
Soy sauce made with wheat that says gluten-free on its labelIn general, soy sauce made from soybeans and wheat may not bear the claim20.
Wheat or wheat starch named in the ingredients of a food that says gluten-freeNot a violation by itself: an ingredient from a gluten grain can be used if it was processed to remove gluten and its use leaves the food under 20 ppm18. FDA adds that a food made with wheat processed to remove gluten, with a claim and wheat declared, must carry a disclaimer saying so21.
“Made in a facility that also processes wheat” next to a gluten-free claimFDA allows the statement if it is truthful and not misleading22; the food must still meet the gluten-free rule18.
Wheat in a food with no gluten-free claim and no wheat declaredWheat is one of the major food allergens named in the allergen labeling law; barley and rye are not named there23. Failure to list a major allergen is one reason FDA gives for recalls24.

If your product falls in the first three rows, say so in your report and name the ingredient. If you are not sure, write down exactly what the label says and report it anyway; FDA states that labeling concerns may be reported3.

What to keep before you contact anyone

FDA’s advice, in its answer for a person who becomes ill after a product labeled gluten-free, is to keep any food packages because they may contain important information3. FDA also lists what it asks a report to include4. Put together, the list for a label problem is:

  1. The package. For meat, poultry and egg products USDA says it needs the original container and any uneaten portion, refrigerated or frozen25.
  2. Photos of the front claim, the full ingredient list, any Contains line, and the lot code, expiration date and UPC code. FDA’s list names the photos of the product, label, ingredient statement and lot code4.
  3. The store, its address and the date you bought it, which is also on FDA’s list4. Keep the receipt if you have one.
  4. A screenshot of the maker’s web page for the product, with the date. One entry on Gluten Free Watchdog’s list notes that a product’s ingredients list on the package differs from the one posted online26.
  5. If you had a reaction: the date, your symptoms, how long after eating they began, medications you used, and whether you needed medical care. That is the detail FDA’s list asks for4.

Tell the maker and the store

Telling the maker is a separate step from reporting. The FDA page for reporting a food problem lists the online portal and the phone line and does not ask you to contact the maker first5, and USDA says you can complain to the store or the maker if you choose not to make a formal complaint to USDA6. A message to the maker is the direct way to ask what is in the product; a report to an agency is how the problem reaches the regulator.

Name the product, the lot code and the ingredient or claim that does not fit, and attach your photos. Our guide on what to ask a food maker covers the questions and how to read the reply.

A maker may answer that an ingredient was processed to remove gluten. In one entry on Gluten Free Watchdog’s list, a maker replied that the barley in its tea “has been processed to allow to meet” FDA’s gluten-free requirements27. If you get that reply, ask where the label says so, since FDA says a food made with wheat processed to remove gluten, bearing a claim and declaring wheat, must carry a disclaimer to that effect21.

Which agency takes the report

Where to send a report, by type of product
ProductWhere it goes
Most packaged foods and dietary supplementsFDA. Its Food and Cosmetic Information Center takes complaints on FDA-regulated food and supplements28, through an online reporting portal or by phone on 1-888-723-33667.
Meat, poultry and egg productsUSDA. Call the Meat and Poultry Hotline on 1-888-674-6854 or report online8. USDA’s online form accepts reports of mislabeling29. FDA’s own page sends meat and poultry problems to USDA30, and FDA regulates the labeling of shell eggs31.
AlcoholTTB. FDA’s contact list gives TTB’s number as 202-453-2000 and says TTB handles consumer complaints about misleading advertising of alcoholic beverages32. For which agency rules on a drink’s label, see who regulates a gluten-free claim.
A restaurant, grocery store or other retail businessState and local regulatory agencies9. USDA’s page also sends restaurant problems to the health department in your city, county or state33.

For unpackaged food, such as restaurant dishes, FDA says it will monitor reports and share the complaints it receives with state and local partners34.

If an older page tells you to call the FDA Consumer Complaint Coordinator for your state, it is out of date. A 2015 Celiac Disease Foundation post, for one, sends readers there35. FDA announced that the phone numbers tied to the coordinators would stop on October 1, 202416, and its coordinators page says the numbers are no longer in use17. FDA says its Human Foods Program now receives and evaluates complaints, and its Office of Inspections and Investigations follows up with firms as needed36.

If you were made ill

For a person who becomes ill after eating a product labeled gluten-free, FDA’s answer is to contact a healthcare provider immediately and keep the packages3. USDA’s page says, “If you think you are ill, see a physician”37. Our own guide, what the celiac organizations say to do after exposure, covers the next steps; this guide covers the report.

An illness report is separate from a labeling report, and you can make both. FDA says a report may be about an adverse event, which it describes as an illness or serious allergic reaction3, and FDA’s list asks for the symptoms and timing4.

Check the recall lists

Recalls for a wrong label are not limited to gluten claims. FDA names failure to list a major allergen on the label as a reason for a recall24. Wheat is one of the major food allergens named in the allergen labeling law, so a product with undeclared wheat can be recalled on that ground; barley and rye are not named there23. In the 2015 Cheerios case, General Mills recalled lots of Cheerios and Honey Nut Cheerios labeled gluten-free “due to the presence of wheat flour (an undeclared allergen)”38. Gluten Free Watchdog reports that recall notices for several sauces, posted to FDA’s enforcement report in December 202039, gave as the reason a gluten-free claim on a product with a fermented soy sauce made from wheat that was not processed to remove gluten40.

  • FDA’s recalls list. It is built from press releases and public notices about certain recalls, and not all recalls have a press release or are posted there10. It has a recall-reason column and a product-type filter41.
  • FDA’s Enforcement Report. It includes all recalls FDA monitors once they are classified, and sometimes earlier11.
  • USDA’s recalls page for meat, poultry and egg products12. It lists current recalls and public health alerts42.

A recall notice helps you match your package: FDA says a recalling firm’s notice to its customers names the product, the package size and type, the UPC, product codes such as lot codes, sell-by or use-by dates, and where the product was sold43. Compare it with your photos.

Not being on FDA’s recalls list does not clear a product, since not all recalls are posted there10. Gluten Free Watchdog reports one recall that was initiated on January 4, 2021 but did not appear in any public FDA notification until April 11, 202244.

What a report does and does not do

FDA says it enforces the gluten-free rule through routine monitoring: sampling, inspections of food manufacturing facilities, label reviews, follow-up on consumer and industry complaints, and, when needed, gluten analyses of food samples1. It says it will consider regulatory action for products found to be misbranded case by case45. Each report is evaluated to decide how serious the problem is and what follow-up is needed2, and reports are logged in a complaint database46.

The 2015 Cheerios case shows one path from reported reactions to a recall. As the Celiac Disease Foundation reported it, FDA tested 36 samples of Cheerios products labeled gluten-free after adverse reactions were reported, and one sample of Honey Nut Cheerios contained 43 ppm of gluten47; the recall followed38. Our verdicts on Cheerios and Honey Nut Cheerios are the place to check where each product stands today.

For scale, FDA’s own sampling from July 2015 to August 201648 collected 702 samples from more than 250 products labeled gluten-free, and only one product was found not to comply with one of the major requirements49. FDA reported that more than 99.5 percent of the sampled products complied50. That sampling dates from 2015 to 2016 and covers one requirement; it does not tell you about your product.

Do not count on a ruling on your product, or on enforcement action, from a report alone. The author of Gluten Free Watchdog’s list writes that, to the best of the author’s knowledge, none of the products it reported to FDA with malt syrup or malt extract and a gluten-free label had been subject to any enforcement action by FDA51. That is one advocate’s account of the group’s own reports, not an FDA statement. It is a reason to keep your own record and to tell the maker as well.

Verdicts in this guide

Questions people ask

Do I have to contact the maker before reporting to FDA?

No. FDA’s report page lists the portal and the phone line without a maker step5. USDA notes that you can complain to the store or the maker if you do not make a formal complaint to USDA6.

Can I report a gluten-free item I was served in a restaurant?

FDA’s rule applies to packaged foods15. FDA says it will monitor reports about unpackaged food and share them with state and local partners34, and it points restaurant complaints to state and local agencies9.

Is wheat starch on a gluten-free label automatically a violation?

No. An ingredient from a gluten grain can be used if it was processed to remove gluten and its use leaves the food under 20 ppm18. Check the label for the disclaimer FDA describes for wheat processed to remove gluten21.

Does FDA test the product when I report it?

FDA lists gluten analyses of food samples “when needed” among its monitoring activities, together with sampling, inspections, label reviews and follow-up on complaints1.

More in Label reading and gluten-free claims

Sources