Fine on bread in Europe? What it does and does not show

Short answer

A symptom-free trip on bread does not show that the bread was lower in gluten, or that gluten did no harm to someone with celiac disease: NIDDK says people with celiac disease who have no symptoms can still develop complications over time if they do not get treatment2. We found no study comparing gluten in European and US wheat12, 13, and the EU and the US both set the limit for a gluten-free claim at 20 parts per million29, 30. For people with self-reported gluten or wheat sensitivity, trials have tested expectation, fructans and wheat species as explanations for symptoms, not European against US wheat16, 18, 23.

Published by Gluten Verdict · updated · 17 sources, each linked below

Reviewed by Mark Peter, Registered dietitian (RD), on

Crusty loaves in a basket at a bakery counter with a waiting customer.

Key points

  • NIDDK says celiac disease symptoms vary widely, and that people with celiac disease who have no symptoms can still develop complications over time if they do not get treatment1, 2.
  • In one 14-day gluten-challenge study of 20 adults with coeliac disease, symptoms were back at baseline by day 28 while antibody titres had risen markedly6, 9.
  • We found no study that compares gluten in European and US wheat12, 13; trials in people with self-reported gluten or wheat sensitivity tested expectation, fructans and wheat species instead17, 21, 24.
  • The EU and the US both use 20 parts per million for a gluten-free claim29, 30, but the EU counts oats in its definition of gluten32 and the US rule does not list oats among gluten-containing grains15.
  • The EU allergen list names rye, barley and oats as well as wheat42; the US list of major food allergens names wheat46.

If you have celiac disease: why “I felt fine” is not a test

NIDDK describes the symptoms of celiac disease as varying widely, and says a person may have symptoms that come and go1. It also says people with celiac disease who have no symptoms can still develop complications over time if they do not get treatment2.

Two studies show how symptoms and the markers of celiac disease can part ways. In a community study that tested blood from residents under 50 of Olmsted County, Minnesota, who had no prior diagnosis, the authors found no typical symptoms or classic consequences of diagnosed celiac disease (diarrhea, anemia or fracture) associated with undiagnosed celiac disease3, 4. They concluded that it appeared clinically silent, with long-term outcomes not yet determined5. The same abstract also reports associations of undiagnosed celiac disease with hypothyroidism and with lower cholesterol and ferritin levels55.

In a gluten-challenge study of 20 adults with biopsy-proven coeliac disease, participants ate 3 or 7.5 g of gluten a day for 14 days6. By day 14, biopsies showed a significant fall in the ratio of villous height to crypt depth and a rise in intraepithelial lymphocytes7, 8. Gastrointestinal symptoms rose by day 3 and were back at baseline by day 28, after the 14-day challenge, by which time antibody titres had risen markedly9.

These studies cannot say how any one person will react to one meal. NIDDK says celiac disease is not diagnosed based on symptoms alone10, and that doctors do not recommend starting a gluten-free diet before diagnostic testing, because the diet can affect test results11.

Is wheat in Europe different from wheat in the US?

In a Europe PMC phrase search and a PubMed search we did not find a study that compares the gluten in European and US wheat, or how people respond to each12, 13. A missing study does not show the wheat is the same; it means there is no comparison to cite either way.

The two rules define wheat by species, not by where it is grown. The EU defines wheat as any Triticum species14, and FDA’s rule counts wheat, including any species of the genus Triticum, as a gluten-containing grain, along with rye and barley15.

Self-reported gluten or wheat sensitivity: what trials have tested

Three trials enrolled people with self-reported sensitivity to gluten or wheat, with celiac disease ruled out, and tested possible reasons for their symptoms16, 18, 23. None of the three compared European with US wheat16, 18, 23.

What three trials compared
TrialWhat was comparedWhat it found
Expectancy trial (2024)Whether people expected gluten-containing or gluten-free oat bread, crossed with whether the oat bread actually contained gluten56The combination of expectancy and actual gluten had the largest effect on symptoms, which the authors read as a nocebo effect; an additional effect of gluten could not be ruled out17
Fructan trial (2018)59 people on a self-instituted gluten-free diet received gluten (5.7 g), fructans (2.1 g) or placebo in muesli bars, each for 7 days18, 19Overall IBS-type symptom scores (GSRS-IBS) were significantly higher with fructans than with gluten, and did not differ between gluten and placebo20, 21
Wheat species and fermentation trial (2024)Bread made from bread wheat, spelt or emmer, yeast-fermented in one study and sourdough-fermented in the other, with 20 people in each23Most people had some symptoms with at least one bread, but as a group there were no differences between grains in either study24

The authors of the fructan trial note that foods with gluten often contain fructans, which they describe as a type of fermentable oligo-, di-, monosaccharides and polyols22.

These trials say nothing about celiac disease, where NIDDK says consuming gluten triggers the abnormal immune system response that causes the disease25.

Sourdough and long fermentation: what one study tested

One 2004 study tested a specific recipe: a sourdough made from a mixture of wheat (30%) and nontoxic oat, millet and buckwheat flours, started with lactobacilli and fermented for 24 hours26.

Two breads containing about 2 g of gluten, one made with baker’s yeast and one with lactobacilli and their cytoplasmic extracts, were used in a double-blind acute challenge of 17 patients with celiac sprue27, 28. Thirteen of the 17 showed a marked alteration of intestinal permeability after the baker’s yeast bread. After the sourdough bread, the same 13 had values that did not differ significantly from baseline, and the other 4 did not respond to either bread28.

That is one small study of one recipe, and it says nothing about a loaf bought in a bakery or café. For those, our sourdough verdict shows what makers and certifiers say.

EU and US gluten-free label rules side by side

Both set the limit for a gluten-free claim at 20 parts per million. The EU text allows no more than 20 mg of gluten per kg of food as sold29; FDA’s text requires any unavoidable gluten to be below 20 ppm, which it restates as below 20 mg per kg30. The wording differs: the EU says “no more than” 20 mg/kg and FDA says “below” 20 ppm, and the table shows further differences.

The gluten-free rules compared
QuestionEuropean UnionUnited States
The ruleCommission Implementing Regulation (EU) No 828/2014, applied from 20 July 20163121 CFR 101.91, FDA’s gluten-free labeling rule30
Which grains count as glutenGluten means a protein fraction from wheat, rye, barley, oats or their crossbred varieties and derivatives32Gluten-containing grains are wheat, rye, barley and their crossbred hybrids; oats are not on that list15
OatsOats in a gluten-free food must be specially produced, prepared or processed to avoid contamination by wheat, rye, barley or their crossbreds, and cannot exceed 20 mg/kg33Oats labeled gluten-free must contain less than 20 ppm gluten; FDA says they do not have to be certified34
A second claim‘Very low gluten’ is allowed where the food contains an ingredient made from wheat, rye, barley, oats or their crossbreds that was specially processed to reduce gluten, at no more than 100 mg/kg35. Coeliac UK says no foods in the UK currently carry that wording, but products in other European countries may36FDA’s rule defines “gluten-free” and applies the same requirements to three other phrases; we found no “very low gluten” claim in the rule’s text37
What it coversInformation to consumers on the absence or reduced presence of gluten in food38; its preamble says this should help people choose a varied diet when eating inside or outside the home39Packaged foods; FDA recommends that restaurants making a “gluten-free” claim on their menus follow its definition40, 41

Allergen labeling: emphasized grains in the EU, a Contains line in the US

For gluten the two allergen lists differ. EU law lists cereals containing gluten, namely wheat, rye, barley, oats, spelt, kamut or their hybridised strains, among the substances that must be labeled42, 43. In the ingredient list, each must be emphasised through a typeset that clearly distinguishes it from the rest of the list, for example by font, style or background colour44. That item of the list carries exceptions, such as wheat based glucose syrups including dextrose and wheat based maltodextrins45.

The US list of major food allergens names wheat, not barley or rye46. US law lets a maker name the allergen in a line that starts with the word Contains, printed immediately after or adjacent to the ingredient list47. Barley and rye are not on that list, so a Contains line is not required to name them46.

EU law also makes allergen information mandatory for food offered for sale without prepackaging, or packed at the consumer’s request48, 57, which covers the Annex II substances such as cereals containing gluten. Member states may adopt national measures on the means through which that information is made available49.

What to check on a package or menu abroad

  1. On a packaged food, look for the words ‘gluten-free’: in the EU the statement may only be made where the food as sold contains no more than 20 mg/kg of gluten29. A statement such as ‘suitable for coeliacs’ may accompany it50.
  2. Read the ingredient list for grains printed in a distinct typeset44, and remember that the allergen list has exceptions such as wheat based glucose syrups45.
  3. Treat ‘very low gluten’ as a different claim from ‘gluten-free’: it allows up to 100 mg/kg35.
  4. If a gluten-free product contains oats, the EU rule requires specially produced oats33.
  5. At a counter or on a menu, ask for the allergen information. EU law makes it mandatory for food sold without prepackaging48, 57, and member states may set how it is given49. Coeliac UK suggests booking restaurants in advance and requesting gluten free meals, then speaking to the chef or front of house staff on arrival to confirm that they have been arranged51.
  6. Carry food you can rely on. Coeliac UK suggests working out what you can rely on in an emergency and packing emergency gluten free snacks52, and, in its notes on gluten free products abroad, says bread and pasta are frequently found in large branches of supermarkets and health food shops, often under the Diet section53.

At home, our verdicts for bread, pasta, pizza, croissants, couscous and sourdough show what makers and certifiers say about each food. A label abroad is a separate check.

Planning the next trip

Coeliac UK says it has travel guides for over 50 countries, with translations of useful phrases54. Our own country guides cover Italy, France, Spain and Portugal, and the travel hub collects them all.

Verdicts in this guide

Questions people ask

Do the EU and the US use the same gluten-free limit?

For the number, yes: the EU text allows no more than 20 mg/kg29 and FDA’s rule requires unavoidable gluten to be below 20 ppm30. The EU also has a ‘very low gluten’ statement, up to 100 mg/kg, for foods with specially processed ingredients35.

Is European wheat lower in gluten than American wheat?

We did not find a study that compares them12, 13. Both rules define wheat by species14, 15.

Can celiac disease cause no symptoms?

NIDDK says people with celiac disease who have no symptoms can still develop complications over time if they do not get treatment2.

Does the EU allergen list include barley and rye?

Yes. It names wheat, rye, barley, oats, spelt and kamut42. The US list of major food allergens names wheat, not barley or rye46.

More in Gluten basics and myths

Sources